|

More on Ummid : International l National Regional l Politics Sports Religion l History l Culture l Education

 

Why Do So Few

Speak Up for Gaza?

Posted on January 11, 2009

Robert Scheer, Truthdig.com

 

 
 

Related Articles

Childhood Is Dying: The United Nations estimated that half a million Iraqi children died during more than 12 years of economic sanctions that preceded the U.S. invasion of March...Read Full

Light through the wall: Life in Rafah, Gaza's southern-most city, has always been difficult. But the period since March 2006 has been the worst in my 25-year life. Israel placed Gaza...Read Full

Is Israel Winning the 'Media War' over Gaza?: "We are all Hamas," screamed a scrawny Mauritanian, repeatedly, as he determinedly drew his face closer to a TV camera. Behind him...Read Full

Revise Your Terror List: Inappropriate use of the term "terrorism" by people with despicable motives is probably the most serious obstacle to peace. Can somebody please explain-Mr Brown?...Read Full

 

 

 
 

 

More on Ummid

'Give the Indian Muslims ten years of

peace': True, the Government initiatives, schemes and policies take time and if they are related to Muslims they take...Read Full

‘Advising Restraint, work for the Revival of the Community’: We should advise the Indian Muslims for observing total restraint so that the Anti-Muslim forces...Read Full

Will Indo-Pak peace bring peace to

beleaguered Indian Muslims? While the secretary-level talks between India and Pakistan has commenced...Read Full

 
 

Communal Harmony Campaign in Malegaon

Let’s work to bring a change: “Deadly RDX was invented by Alfred Nobel but we find Peace Prizes being given every year in his name. At one time training camps and hijacking classes were order of the day in United States. However it witnessed a pleasant...Read Full
Confidence overrule the fear: The returned figure of the references resulting after a keyword search about Malegaon at any search engine on the Internet is impressive enough to envy any place. However a glance at the list relating the town with the riots and the bomb blast is so embarrassing that people are becoming shy of associating themselves with Malegaon...Read Full
Malegaon to host Communal Harmony Week:Supported by several organizations and educational institutions of the town, Malegaon Municipal Corporation is organizing a Communal Harmony and National Integration program in terror stricken Malegaon that will commence on Wednesday November 19, 2008. The program that will continue for a whole week will be inaugurated by State Minority Commission Chairman Naseem Siddiquee at 11:00 in the...Read Full

RTI ACT is a Boon: Right to Information Act (RTI), experts say is the most important act ever passed in post Independence India. One of the primary motives behind this act is to check the rampant corruption in the country. But has its implantation resulted in the desired results?...Read Full

 
 

...A Tribute to Prophet Mohammad

A Tribute to Prophet Mohammad

Fourteen hundred and thirty-seven years ago in 571 CE on 9th or 12th of Rabi Al Oola, the ongoing month of Islamic calendar, a baby was born in one of the most respected household of Makkah. Abdul Mutallib, the chief of Banu Hashim, as the household was referred to as, and the grandfather of the newly born was ecstatic. “Ecstatic, Abdul Mutallib took his grand son to Holy Ka’ba. Prayed for him and named him as Mohammad”, narrates 15-year old Zinneerah Tabassum, a student at Kulliyah Aisha.

...Read Full

Prophet Mohammed: A Messiah for Our Time

Prejudice is like poison. Unless purged out of one’s mind in early stages, it can spread like cancer and make one incapable of differentiating between right and wrong. Of the many kinds of prejudice, the worst is to believe that one’s own religion is superior to all others, which may be tolerated but never taken seriously or accepted as equally valid as one’s own.

...Read Full

 
 

Why are we so indifferent to the death and destruction in Gaza?

The major news outlets meekly accepted Israel’s banning of journalists from entering Gaza as an excuse for downplaying collateral civilian casualties, our president-elect, Barack Obama, has had little to say about an invasion that will much complicate his future Mideast peace efforts, and most commentators easily rationalize Israel’s many-more-eyes-for-an-eye killings.

Why is it that there is such widespread acceptance, beginning with the apologetic arguments of President Bush, that whatever Israel does is always justified as necessary to the survival of the Jewish state?

It is not.

While the Hamas rocket attacks are reprehensible, they are also an ineffectual challenge to Israel’s enormous security apparatus, and the severity of Israel’s response to them is counterproductive. Clearly, the very existence of Israel is not now, nor has it ever been, seriously challenged by anything the Palestinians did. Not back in 1948, when Israel was established as a state with insignificant Palestinian military resistance, nor at the time of the 1967 Six-Day War when Egypt, Syria and Jordan fought Israel.

The Palestinians were in no position to confront the Israeli army, because those whose lands were not already occupied by Israel were living under oppressive Egyptian control in Gaza and tough Jordanian rule in the West Bank. After the speedy Israeli victory, which demolished the myth of the new state’s vulnerability, the Palestinians became imprisoned as a people by Israel for crimes they had not committed.

 

Even if we accept the harshest portrayal of the tactics and motives of the Palestinian movements against Israel after the Six-Day War, at what point did that terrorism represent a serious challenge to the survival of the Jewish people or the state that claims to speak in their name? Yet that survival is invoked to justify the vastly excessive use of force by the Israeli war machine, with frequent allusions to the Holocaust previously visited upon the Jewish people, a holocaust that had nothing to do with Palestinians or Muslims, and everything to do with Central Europeans claiming to be Christians.

The high moral claim of the Israeli occupation rests not on the objective reality of a Palestinian threat to Israel’s survival, but rather on the non sequitur cry that “never again” should harm come to Jews as it did in Central Europe seven decades ago.

The basic argument is that Palestinian terrorists represented by Hamas are given to an irrational hatred of Jews so profound that it invalidates their movement, even when they win elections. That was not the view of the Israeli security service when it earlier supported Hamas as the alternative to the then dreaded PLO. Also, history is replete with examples of terrorists becoming statesmen, even within the early ranks of Jews fighting to establish the state of Israel.

One of those was Menachem Begin, who went on to be an elected leader of the new state. But before Begin attained that respectability, back in 1948 when he visited the United States, a group of prominent Jewish intellectuals including Albert Einstein, Sidney Hook and Hannah Arendt wrote a letter to The New York Times warning that Begin was a former leader of the “Irgun Zvai Leumi, a terrorist, right-wing, chauvinist organization in Palestine.” The letter urged Jews to shun Begin, arguing, “It is inconceivable that those who oppose fascism throughout the world, if correctly informed as to Mr. Begin’s political record and perspectives, could add their names and support to the movement he represents.”

Begin’s new party was then participating in the Israeli election, and Einstein and his colleagues, many of whom like the physicist had been victims of German fascism, stated, “Today they speak of freedom, democracy and anti-imperialism, whereas until recently they openly preached the doctrine of the Fascist state. It is in its actions that the terrorist party betrays its real character.”

Those actions were then detailed in the letter. They included the systematic terrorizing of innocent Palestinian men, women and children in an effort to force them to flee the territory that Begin’s party claimed for the new state of Israel.

Clearly Begin and his political heirs, who include Benjamin Netanyahu, the most likely victor in the next Israeli election, evolved in their behavior. But I bring it up now to highlight the one-sided reporting of the current phase of this interminable conflict and to wonder: Where are the voices that reflect the uncompromising morality of Einstein’s generation of Jewish intellectuals willing to acknowledge fault and humanity on both sides of the political equation?

 

 

 

 

 

                                                         Home | Top of the page      

 
   

  Your Ad Here

 

  Comment on this article

 

Name:
E-mail Address:
Write here...
 
 

 

 
 

  Your Ad Here

 

Ummid.com: Home | Contact Us | Disclaimer | Terms of Use | About Us | Feedback

Ummid Business: Advertise with us | Careers | Link Exchange

Ummid.com is part of Awaz Multimedia & Publications providing World News, News Analysis and Feature Articles on Education, Health. Politics, Technology, Sports, Entertainment, Industry etc. The articles or the views displayed on this website are for public information and in no way describe the editorial views. The users are entitled to use this site subject to the terms and condition mentioned.