Follow us on
Welcome Guest! You are here: Home » Views & Analysis
Uttar Pradesh Verdict – Glass Half Empty or Half Full

Tuesday March 14, 2017 2:33 PM, Syed Ali Mujtaba,

Modi Victory March in Delhi

My analysis of Uttar Pradesh election result which basically pointed out the failure of the secularist and their shortfalls to live up to the people’s expectation is dubbed as kindergarten OP ED by some of my readers.

I like to tell them, we live in postmodern age; the era when everything is measured in either black or white no more exits. In postmodern age, the truth is glass half empty as well as half full. It can’t be singular fact alone. This is what I intended to say in my previous analysis on UP results.

Now, I have to write another piece that would say BJP victory was more due to consolidation of caste Hindu votes in its favor. It was also because the division of Muslim votes between two parties, the split led to the benefit of the third party, the BJP.

The result also suggests that India is moving towards majoritarian democracy, the verdict also endorse that ‘unity in diversity’ has lost its meaning and ‘Hindutva’ alone is Indian nationalism.

The verdict also suggests that the consolidation of Hindu votes shattered the myth of the invincibility of Muslim vote bank that was counted to be the deciding factor of the poll outcome.

The UP results also point out to the fact that the Muslims who are already lowly represented in political power structure will be further be marginalized hereafter.

The verdict also threatens the Muslims that their life, security and honor are only safe in the hands of the BJP. Further, if they nurse any idea of resistance against the Hindutva forces they can be lynched like “Ekhlaq” on a public square, and none can care too hoots about them.

The verdict also sounds that there can be more ‘Muzafarnagar’ kind of riots and Muslims have to live in refugee camps.

Such argument can be built on and on and there is no end to them. All could be part of the constructed truth and I do not deny them anyway.

However, my submission is ‘democracy’ entails periodic rotation of majorities and no party can claim monopoly over it. In the recent election, the Punjab verdict is example of this fact.

In this context, I repeat that BJP won the UP vote by default and not as an endorsement of its ‘Hindutva’ ideas. People in UP wanted a change and the mandate is to test some other political party that could provide a better governance.

People have voted above Mandal vs Kamandal as both have not provided any tangible results to them and only pandered to their raw emotions. The UP verdict is for showing concrete results and tangible benefits to the people and not to keep them captivated in one camp or other.

The fact that the BJP did not try to polarize the society on communal lines, they played no communal cards during electioneering, suggests that the party is conscious of its harms than the gains.

They just campaigned against its opponents failures and got the reward. The fact that their opponents could no way stop them from capturing power and that is the reason BJP won the UP vote.

Well someone said why did not Samajwadi, Bahujan Samaj Party (BSP) and the Congress joined hands and contested the poll together. In such a case the outcome could have been on Bihar’s lines. Well that’s exactly I too tried to argue that the victory of the BJP is more due the failure of the secular parties, than the saffron pull that crafted its victory.

[Syed Ali Mujtaba is a journalist based in Chennai. He can be contacted at]



Share this page
More Headlines
'Pink noise' can help oldies sleep their way to better memory
Third time MLA Raziya Sultana is only Muslim legislator in 117-member Punjab Assembly
Pilgrims on Umrah likely to get extended visa, chance to visit other cities in Saudi Arabia
Manohar Parrikar back in Goa as Chief Minister
Manipur: Congress MLA, lone Trinamool Congress legislator join BJP: Himanta Biswa Sarma
Prime Minister Modi asks people to pledge to create 'New India' by 2022
Muslim votes went to BJP, Shaista Amber and Mayawati both believe so, but for different reasons
60-member Manipur Assembly will have 03 Muslim MLAs
BJP majority Uttar Pradesh Assembly to have 24 Muslim MLAs, second fewest in its history
Netherlands detains Turkish minister, forcibly deports her to Germany
End of ‘Kamandal’ vs ‘Mandal’ Politics in Uttar Pradesh
Dr Mohd Ayub of Peace Party loses in Khalilabad; Zafar Alam of SP dislodged in Aligarh
Tasleem Ahmad, Masood Akhtar of SP among winners in Uttar Pradesh
Mohammad Abdullah, 26-yr-old son of SP stalwart Azam Khan, wins 2017 UP elections
Mukhtar Ansari wins from Mau, Haji Ikram Qureshi romps home Moradabad Rural
Imran Masood of Congress loses Nakur seat to BJP by 4,000 votes
Sibgatullah Ansari of BSP loses Mohammadabad seat to BJP in straight fight
Senior SP leader Azam Khan wins Rampur assembly seat by over 45,000 votes
Nahid Hasan of Samajwadi Party defeats BJP candidate in Kairana, Uttar Pradesh
Brijesh Singh of BJP defeats Maviya Ali in Muslim dominated Deoband, Uttar Pradesh

 Post Comments
Note: By posting your comments here you agree to the terms and conditions of