Follow us on
Welcome Guest! You are here: Home » India
Standing in queues for hours traumatic: SC on demonetisation, cash shortage
Tuesday November 15, 2016 11:20 PM, IANS

Supreme Court

New Delhi:
The Supreme Court on Tuesday asked the Centre to explain the steps it has taken or will take to deal with chaos outside banks and ATMs following the demonetisation move and observed that people should not suffer.

Asking the Centre to file a reply without formally issuing notice, a bench of Chief Justice T.S. Thakur and Justice D.Y. Chandrachud said they will not interfere with the government policy but said standing in queues for hours was traumatic.

Refusing to stay the November 8 decision to demonetise Rs 500 and Rs 1,000 currency, as sought by one the four petitioners, Chief Justice Thakur told Attorney General Mukul Rohatgi: " ...instead of forcing citizens to stand in queues for their own money, why can't you raise their cash withdrawal to a reasonable limit? It is traumatic for people to stand in lines for hours doing nothing."

"We are wondering if you can do something to reduce the trauma of the common people," the bench said as senior counsel Kapil Sibal told the bench that it was the small sellers or street vendors who were suffering the most as they are dependent on cash transactions.

Sibal, appearing for one of the petitioners, described demonetisation as a "surgical strike against the common man".

Pointing to hardships faced by the people and provisions of the law governing demonetisation of notes, Sibal said: "You can have surgical strikes against black money but you can't have surgical strikes against the common people."

Chief Justice Thakur observed: "What Attorney General says is a surgical strike; what you say is carpet bombing."

Makings it clear that he was not seeking a stay on the government decision, Sibal said: "We are with the government in curbing black money; but the inconvenience it is causing to the public is not reasonable. It is jeopardising their lives."

Pointing out that 86 per cent of the currency had gone out of circulation, the petitioner's counsel said: "It is my money. It is legitimate money, tax paid. Under what law of the land can you restrict my right to withdraw my money?"

Defending the demonetisation decision as conforming with legal provisions, Attorney General Mukul Rohatgi admitted that the government decision of such magnitude would cause some pain and urged the court not to interfere as "these are the matters of economic policy".

At this, Chief Justice Thakur observed: "We are not interfering in your policy matters."

Contesting Sibal's contention that the government did not follow the law before demonetisation, Rohatgi said: "You can't pass a law saying we are going to issue a notification for the demonetisation of currency notes of certain denomination...."

Saying there will be "some pain (to common people) if there is a surgical strike against black money", Rohatgi said there were pains "in the past too for getting a scooter (two-wheeler), Fiat car, telephone, ration ..."

Telling the court that the aim was to flush out black money and stop terror funding, the Attorney General said: "Some collateral damage will take place. I could not calibrate the two lakh ATMs (in the country) as that would have brought the cat out of the bag." This position has been articulated by Finance Minister Arun Jaitley.

The Attorney General said Rs 3.25 lakh crore in Rs 500 and Rs 1,000 notes had been deposited since demonetisation. He said it was out of the Rs 15 to Rs 16 lakh crore that is in circulation. He said the government expected Rs 10 to 11 lakh crore to come to banks.

Addressing the concerns shown by the court, the Attorney General said every day we are adding Rs 10,000 crore to the economy and said that inconvenience alone could not be a ground against demonetisation.


Share this page
More Headlines
Keith Ellison, first Muslim elected to US Congress, Democratic Party savior?
New signs above Black Stone to help pilgrims performing Tawaf around Kaaba
Prof Rifaat Ahmed Abdel Karim conferred Royal Award for Islamic Finance 2016
US may have committed war crimes in Afghanistan: ICC prosecutor
Congress to oppose GST if four slabs of taxation up to 28 per cent introduced
Class X board exam for CBSE schools to be reintroduced from 2017-18
Loom owners pay banned 500/1000 notes in wages, add to the pain of labourers
Demonetisation scheme announced without proper preparedness by RBI: Bank unions
Corrupts are upset after demonetisation, says PM Modi; Opposition hits back
Israel passes law to reduce volume of Adhan from mosque speakers
Fears of 'fake' new notes: Some quick ways to identify authenticity
News channels paint Kashmir black for the sake of TRPs: Mehbooba Mufti
OIC to hold ministerial meeting on Houthi missile attack targeting Makkah
Did banks ignore RBI order on Rs 100-ATMs before demonetisation?
Delhi HC seeks CBSE's reply on plea for name change in certificates
Two differing medications safe for patient undergoing heart procedure
Donald Trump vows to immediately deport up to three million immigrants
Pakistan's strategic Gwadar port opens China-Pakistan Economic Corridor
NATO chief warns Trump against 'going it alone'
With anger rising, govt eases withdrawal norms
Curfew, tension in Vidisha town of Madhya Pradesh after Bajrang Dal leader killed
BJP MP Kirit Somaiya to release list of companies with black money
 Post Comments
Note: By posting your comments here you agree to the terms and conditions of