Education Scholarships

Direct link to the various education scholarships offered by the Government of India

List of Private NGOs offering education scholarships

Ummid Assistant

Application form for OBC & Domicile Certificate Certificates (Urdu)

Admission open to AMU off campus centers at Murshidabad (WB) and at Malappuram (Kerala). Click here for admission form.

Welcome Guest! You are here: Home » Views & Analysis

What led to Maharashtra's poverty of leadership

Saturday November 06, 2010 11:07:01 AM, Amulya Ganguli, IANS

Related Article

Kahin Khushi Kahin Gham

One can understand the agony of the Chief Minister and his care for the state when he said Kahin Khushi Kahin Gham reacting on the Railway budget. However we write this with utmost  »

Although the Congress' decision to exclude Maharashtra Chief Minister Ashok Chavan from its election campaign in Bihar is not headline news at the national level, it still has damaging implications for the party.

Chavan is the second chief minister to be kept out of Bihar. The first was his Gujarat counterpart Narendra Modi. In the latter's case, the decision - though formally the Bharatiya Janata Party's (BJP) - was in response to Janata Dal-United (JD-U) leader and Bihar Chief Minister Nitish Kumar's objections on account of Modi's anti-minority reputation.

In Chavan's case, however, the decision is his own party's. What is more, it has nothing to do with any unavoidable or wilful administrative lapses or political motivation, as in Modi's case, but with the charges of corruption which Chavan is facing.

As a result, it is something of a first. It is not often that a chief minister - and that too of such a large and important state like Maharashtra - turns out to be so much of an embarrassment for his party that he cannot be allowed to go on a public stage. In this respect, the Congress as well as Maharashtra has much to be ashamed of.

In a way, Maharashtra's decline has been quite precipitous. There was a time when it was regarded as one of the best-run states and Bombay, as it was known till 1995, a model metropolis, which was replacing Calcutta, as it was known till 2001, as India's premier town.

Although the standards of politicians were nowhere near that of Tilak and Gokhale, Maharashtra still had in Y.B. Chavan someone competent enough to be summoned to New Delhi at a time of national crisis to replace V.K. Krishna Menon as defence minister after the Chinese invasion. After Chavan's departure from the state, there has been no one who can be held up as someone worthy of emulation. Sharad Pawar showed promise for a while but did not live up to it.

It is the poverty of leadership in recent years and the earlier bifurcation of the former Bombay state into Maharashtra and Gujarat that are responsible for the state's decline and fall. The roots of parochialism, which were sown during the Samyukta (united) Maharashtra movement, are eroding its reputation today. Not surprisingly, one of the leaders of the agitation was Prabodhankar Thackeray, whose son, Balasaheb, set up the Shiv Sena in 1966, a fascistic outfit which thrives on violence and the targeting of vulnerable groups like Muslims and north Indian vendors and taxi drivers.

What is unfortunate is that if the Congress had been true to its pluralistic principles, it could have routed the Sena soon after its formation. Instead, the party nurtured the Sena surreptitiously in order to use its cadres to attack and undermine the communist trade unions.

Over the years, fascism triumphed over communism - as it did in Germany in the 1930s and '40s - and well-known communist and socialist leaders of Maharashtra like S.A. Dange, Madhu Dandavate and Mrinal Gore gradually lost their influence. The main gainer was the Congress, for the Sena was destined to remain a minor party. But the loser was the state, which earned a reputation for intolerant sectarianism because of the Sena's depredations.

It was perhaps inevitable that the Congress' political pusillanimity in the matter of countering the Sena's parochialism would foster leaders who would be unable to evoke respect and admiration. Chavan, therefore, is not an oddity, but the outcome of a clear declining trend.

One of the first signs of this fall was the inadequacies which Sudhakar Naik displayed as chief minister during the Mumbai riots of December 1992 after the Babri masjid demolition. Despite pleas from prominent citizens for firm steps against the lawless elements, Naik remained a virtual helpless spectator of the outbreak while the previously highly rated Mumbai Police disgraced itself by its communal outlook, which can be directly ascribed to the insidious influence of the Sena on the lower levels of the force.

Although the Congress, which lost power after the riots, regained it in 1999 and has managed to hold on to it, the reason is not the party's shining image, but the failures of the BJP and the Shiv Sena (which split in 2006) to provide a credible alternative. But neither Maharashtra nor Mumbai has been able to recover the kind of prestige that they enjoyed in the middle of the last century.

While Kolkata has degenerated even more than Mumbai, it is cities like Bengaluru, Hyderabad and Chennai which have emerged as new hubs of the corporate sector. New Delhi too is no longer the sleepy, bureaucratic town it used to be.

Mumbai is still the country's financial capital and the home of Bollywood. But it is living on borrowed time and past prestige. While the underworld "dons" are no longer as active as before, it is the political "dons" of the Shiv Sena and its offshoot, the Maharashtra Navnirman Sena, which are the bane of those who come into Mumbai from Bihar, Uttar Pradesh and elsewhere to earn a living.

And "rulers" like Chavan, who is mired in a housing society scam, let the two Senas survive because they undercut each other during elections.


(Amulya Ganguli is a political analyst. He can be reached at





  Bookmark and Share                                          Home | Top of the Page

Comment on this article

E-mail Address:
Write here...

News Pick

Egypt unearths 3,400-year-old Pharaoh statue

A 3,400-year-old statue of Pharaoh Amenhotep III was discovered in southern Egypt, Xinhua reported. The secretary-general of the Supreme Council of Antiquities (SCA), Zahi Hawwas said Thursday it is one of the  »

Plane with 68 on board crashes in Cuba

A Cuban passenger plane with 68 people on board, 28 among them foreigners, crashed late Thursday, authorities said, without specifying whether there were any survivors. According to the Cuban civil aeronautics institute  »

The Cultural Disconnect

When I sent out my article on gender issues and my critique of the feudal/patriarchal society of Hyderabad, the muted response from the Urdu media in this city eloquently bespoke of the prevailing mindsets in the city. It was ironic that while Muslims  »

20 sentenced to life for murder of 3 Dalits

Twenty people were sentenced to life imprisonment by a court here Thursday for killing three Dalits 17 years ago during a clash over allowing members of the Dalit community to enter a village temple. Additional Sessions  »

48 killed as Indonesian volcano erupts again

At least 48 people were killed and 66 seriously injured Friday by clouds of searing ash and lava from the latest eruptions of Indonesia's Mount Merapi volcano, hospital staff said. In the nearby city of Yogyakarta, Sardjito   »

'Teesta Setalvad not worried about court probe'

The Citizens for Justice and Peace, the Mumbai-based voluntary organization fighting for the 2002 Gujarat riot victims, stated Thursday that its »

More Headlines

India celebrates Diwali with diyas, sweets and pujas

Where Diwali is celebrated with cane fights!

Peaceniks welcome end to Attari border 'confrontation'

Hundreds of foetuses, newborns dumped in South Africa every year

US consul-general apologises to Chavan, Bhujbal

Weak at maths? Try zapping your brain!

21 killed in Karachi plane crash

Nitish hits poll trail on Diwali, rivals in festive spirit

Plane with 68 on board crashes in Cuba

48 killed as Indonesian volcano erupts again

Plane crashes in Karachi, 20 on board

Egypt unearths 3,400-year-old Pharaoh statue

Thousands protest Pope's visit to Spain

'Teesta Setalvad not worried about court probe'




Top Stories

India set to receive Obama

India's financial capital Mumbai was set to receive US President Barack Obama at the start of his four-day visit to India beginning mid-day Saturday. Obama is accompanied by his wife Michelle and top officials in   »

Obama creates buzz among Delhi, Mumbai college-goers

Obama on mission to sell more to India, create US jobs


Picture of the Day

President of India Mrs Pratibha Devisingh Patil receiving greetings from all walks of life, on the occasion of “Diwali”, at Rashtrapati Bhavan, in New Delhi on November 05, 2010.


  Most Read

Peaceniks welcome end to Attari border 'confrontation'

On the eve of US President Barack Obama's visit to Asia starting Saturday, Indian and Pakistani peace activists Friday welcomed the end of the face-to-face show of bravado at the Attari border between the two countries. In a statement, the activists expressed happiness  »

Hundreds of foetuses, newborns dumped in South Africa every year

Hundreds of foetuses and dead newborns are being dumped in the Johannesburg and Pretoria area each year, a South African radio station reported Friday. Johannesburg's private 702 radio station quoted a report by the South African Medical Research Council and the Pretoria-based  »



RSS  |  Contact us

| Quick links



Subscribe to

Ummid Assistant






About us




Government Schemes











Contact us





      Disclaimer | Terms of Use | Advertise with us | Link Exchange is part of the Awaz Multimedia & Publications providing World News, News Analysis and Feature Articles on Education, Health. Politics, Technology, Sports, Entertainment, Industry etc. The articles or the views displayed on this website are for public information and in no way describe the editorial views. The users are entitled to use this site subject to the terms and conditions mentioned.

© 2010 Awaz Multimedia & Publications. All rights reserved.