Opposition slams PM for statement on WikiLeaks revelations

Wednesday March 23, 2011 08:05:36 PM, IANS

New Delhi: The Left and the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) Wednesday attacked Prime Minister Manmohan Singh for his not-guilty statement following allegations that the Congress had bought MPs in the 2008 trust vote and accused him of concealing facts.

The government stood by the prime minister's statement, citing the 2009 election triumph as a defence of the allegation in the US diplomatic cables leaked by WikiLeaks and published by a newspaper and said that the opposition was suffering from "selective amnesia".

The prime minister in his March 18 statement had refuted the charges made in the "speculative, unverified and unverifiable" US diplomatic communications.

Communist Party of India (CPI) leader Gurudas Dasgupta initiated the debate in the Lok Sabha on what has come to be known as the cash-for-votes scam.

"His (prime minister's) statement was firm, normally he is not. But linguistic fervour is something he has used to conceal facts."

He said the parliamentary committee that probed the scandal in 2008 had recommended that it be "appropriately investigated further" and the case was handed over to Delhi Police Crime Branch.

"In a serious case like this, the appropriate probe was left to the Crime Branch, not the CBI (Central Bureau of Investigation), not the Enforcement Directorate and not the Income Tax department.

"I have a feeling, excuse me. Appropriate inquiry was deliberately not done. Why? Because some political businessmen had to be ensured that will remain in the background," Dasgupta alleged.

Dasgupta said the prime minister's justification of highlighting electoral victory after the scandal "cannot hide criminality if it has been committed".

"Over-emphasising the poll verdict by the PM has not brought honours to him. I suppose there is a tendency to propound a dangerous theory that might is right."

Leader of Opposition Sushma Swaraj backed the Left MP. Citing the 1984 anti-Sikh riots and the 2002 sectarian violence in Gujarat, she said Manmohan Singh was rewriting criminal jurisprudence by bringing in the 2009 electoral victory to defend his government.

The BJP leader asked if the prime minister was willing to apply the same yardstick to Gujarat Chief Minister Narendra Modi for the 2002 anti-Muslim riots in that state.

"In Gujarat, Modi has won the assembly elections twice but still the 2002 riot cases are being pursued against him. In Gujarat, in two consecutive elections, you made the 2002 riots an issue, but Narendra Modi won a huge majority."

Despite the victories in Gujarat, Sushma Swaraj said the BJP never demanded that the cases against BJP leaders and workers should be dropped.

"Election victory or defeat cannot wipe away any crime. The episode has shamed India. It has blemished our democratic tradition," she added.

"Since you have great liking for Urdu and Urdu poetry, Manmohan Singh ji, let me recite a couplet today. Tu idhar udhar ki na baat kar, yeh bata ki qaafila kyon loota; hamein rahzanon se gila nahin, teri rehbari ka sawaal hai." (Don't talk hearsay, tell us why the caravan was looted; we have no grouse against dacoits but it is a question of your leadership)

As the opposition joined hands, Parliamentary Affairs Minister P.K. Bansal said the prime minister's statement should have been enough to clear any doubt "but the opposition leaders believe that their utterances are divine truths, they suffer from selective amnesia".

Bansal asked the opposition MPs "not to fall victims to cyber terrorism" -- a phrase the US used to describe the whistleblower WikiLeaks for exposing secret and confidential diplomatic cables.

"The PM has given the statement on the basis of facts. He couldn't have asked for your choice of words. Or you want him to do so?

"You throw stones at us. We don't throw them back because we want to create a bridge between (the government and opposition) with those stones to bridge the differences," Bansal said.

 

                                           Home | Top of the Page

Top Stories

Narendra Modi unapologetic on the Gujarat carnage: US Diplomat

In a comment that can hamper Narendra Modi's image building campaign, US Consul General Michael S. Owen, in a released US cable   »

Tackle US meddling in India: Narendra Modi

 Indian PM seems to be misleading public on cables: WikiLeaks chief

  Most Read

Gaddafi appears in public, vows to fight on

Libyan leader Muammar Gaddafi made a public appearance near Tripoli, vowing to fight on, as the Western countries led by   »

'Gaddafi's daughter Aisha is Claudia Schiffer of North Africa'

US court asks Congress to answer charges on 1984 attacks on Sikhs

 India's Congress party has been asked to respond by April 1 to "summons" issued by a US court to answer charges of "conspiring, aiding, abetting and organizing" attacks on Sikhs in November 1984. The US District Court for the Southern District of New York issued the summons   »

  News Pick

Riot victims in Gujarat still live in unbearable surroundings

Zakat Foundation of India Chairman, Dr. Syed Zafar Mahmood, in a meeting in New Delhi after returning from Gujarat tour said that most of the riot-affected   »

Gujarat riots: Report sought on damaged religious structures

Amnesty report should be examined in totality: Omar

Chief Minister Omar Abdullah Tuesday said that Amnesty International's report on alleged human rights abuses in Jammu and Kashmi  »

End rights abuses in Kashmir, Amnesty tells India

Students' stir disrupts exams in Aligarh university

All important activities in the Aligarh Muslim University (AMU), including admissions and examinations, remained paralyzed Tuesday on account of the forced locking of the central offices by the students' union a day earlier.  »

Fukushima Fallout: Bhopal gas survivors demand re-look of nuclear plants

Following the catastrophic tragedy that struck Japan in the aftermath of the earthquake and Tsunami on March 11 last, the leaders of five NGOs working for the survivors of the December 1984   »

Nitish Kumar floats 99 lamps to kickstart Bihar Divas

The much-awaited Bihar Divas celebrations were inaugurated Tuesday with Chief Minister Nitish Kumar floating 99 lamps in the presence of hundreds of people at the historic Gandhi Maidan to mark the 99th anniversary    »

Picture of the Day

President of India Mrs. Pratibha Devisingh Patil addressing at the inauguration of the National Festival of Tribal Dances, ‘PRAKRITI’, in New Delhi on March 16, 2011. Union Minister for Housing and Urban Poverty Alleviation and Culture, Kum. Selja, Union Minister for Tribal Affairs Kantilal Bhuria and Minister of State for Tribal Affairs Mahadev S. Khandela are also seen.

(Photo: Mukesh Kumar)