Ummid Assistant

Samsung sets up fund for poor kids' education

US varsity offers doctorate for education professionals

Welcome Guest! You are here: Home Views & Analysis

Despite exoneration, Narendra Modi cannot play national role

Saturday April 14, 2012 08:10:48 PM, Amulya Ganguli, IANS

Related Articles

Modi gets clean chit in Gulberg massacre; Zakia vows to fight

A special panel probing the 2002 Gujarat riots has given a clean to Chief Minister Narendra Modi, absolving the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) leader of the   

Authorities in Gujarat protecting perpetrators of 2002 riots: HRW

Politics of hatred has triumphed in Gujarat: Harsh Mander

Narendra Modi's career provides a classic example of how a kinky ideology can thwart political ambitions in a pluralistic society. Yet, when the same ideological outlook enabled him to scale the heights of political power by winning the 2002 assembly elections in Gujarat, the chief minister must have presumed that even greater successes were in store for him.

What he hadn't taken into account were the imperatives of a multicultural country. Till the 2002 elections, Modi was operating within the parameters of the Bharatiya Janata Party's (BJP) world view based on the concept of cultural nationalism or one nation, one people, one culture.

The obvious similarity of this slogan with Nazi Germany's ein volk, ein Reich, ein Fuehrer (one people, one nation, one leader) underlines the fascistic basis of the idea. But neither Modi nor the BJP was bothered. They believed they were on a roll at the time.

However, it was the jolt of the defeat in the 2004 parliamentary polls, which woke them up to the realities of Indian broadmindedness.

Moreover, Atal Bihari Vajpayee's belief that the 2002 Gujarat riots were responsible for the BJP's defeat two years later might have also induced both Modi and his party to mull over their past policies.

Hence, the chief minister's new emphasis on development for all the people of Gujarat. There was no more mocking of the minorities by him as when he crassly described the camps of riot victims as child-producing factories or took care to pronounce the then chief election commissioner's full name of James Michael Lyngdoh to stress his Christianity, which, according to V.D. Savarkar, is a religion alien to India, like Islam.

But none of it has helped Modi, the man who was described by Ashis Nandy as a "textbook case of a fascist and a prospective killer, perhaps even a future mass murderer". The social commentator was prescient, for the last phrase was used by journalists for the chief minister after the riots.

Indeed, this is the charge he still faces and even after his latest exoneration by the Supreme Court-appointed Special Investigating Team (SIT) - the Nanavati commission had earlier given Modi a clean chit in its interim report - the public perception about his complicity continues.

Because of this belief, even the SIT's report has aroused disbelief with a prominent Muslim resident of Gujarat, J.S. Bandukwala, calling it "compromised".

Of course, no final word has yet been said about Modi's role. Even the SIT report was only about the mob violence in the Gulberg housing society where the former Congress MP, Ehsan Jafri, was killed. The report will now be considered by the trial court while the views of the amicus curiae, Raju Ramachandran, are yet to be made public.

However, the point is not the prolonged legal battles, but the fact that Modi's strenuous attempts from the post-2004 poll results to put the riots behind him haven't cleansed his image.

It has been said that one of the reasons why the outbreak, which he callously described as "stray incidents" although 1,200 people were killed, continues to haunt him is that he has never expressed remorse, as Manmohan Singh has done about the 1984 anti-Sikh riots.

However, even if he does say sorry at some point, it may not make much of an impact for two reasons: one is that the BJP itself remains committed to its "one culture" ideal for India, which emphasises the country's Hindu character to the exclusion of all minority cultures, as in a theocracy.

The other reason is that Modi represents, perhaps because of his grim visage, the type of person who can be expected to implement this sectarian vision. This is the reason why he is a hero to large sections of the saffron brotherhood and is persona non grata to liberals and also groups and individuals in the BJP-led National Democratic Alliance (NDA), who are aware that elections cannot be won without accommodating the minorities.

Modi, then, is fighting a losing battle. Moreover, he has fallen between two stools. He can no longer resurrect his minority-baiting self which he flaunted from the time of the anti-Christian disturbances in Gujarat's Dangs area, where the present terror suspect, Assemananda, was an activist, to the 2004 elections.

And he must have realized by now that all his 'sadbhavna' fasts in aid of social harmony, and all his success in providing bijli, sadak and pani (electricity, roads and water) to the voters, which help other politicians, will not enable him to play a national role, which he apparently intends to do.

The riots, for which the Gujarat high court has castigated the state government, and the demolition of the Babri mosque 10 years earlier, were the fallout of the Hindutva camp's virulent communal propaganda. While the 1992 act of destruction helped the BJP to attain power at the centre, the 2002 outbreak made the party lose it. Evidently, the square peg of communalism cannot fit into the round hole of a secular democracy.


Amulya Ganguli is a political analyst. He can be reached at




Home | Top of the Page


Note: By posting your comments here you agree to the terms and conditions of

Comments powered by DISQUS






Top Stories

Raj Thackeray's terror-haven: Partymen shocked, Malegaon criticise

Even as the Muslim supporters of the Maharashtra Navnirman Sena (MNS) are shocked over Raj Thackeray's statement that Malegaon - the Muslim dominated town in North Maharashtra, is a safe haven for terrorists, he is receiving flak from the Malegaonians.  

Malegaon, Bhiwandi safe havens for terrorists: Raj Thackeray

Raj Thackeray challenges Nitish to celebrate Bihar Divas in Mumbai


  Most Read

Shah Rukh victim of US random selection system

When India's star actor Shah Rukh Khan was detained and questioned for two hours at the Newark International Airport in August, 2009, the action could 

Mughal Emperor Akbar was creator of modern India: Justice Katju

Justice Markandey Katju, Chairman of Press Council of India, who was guest of honour on the occasion said Mughal Emperor Akbar the Great is the creator of modern India who enunciated the 


  News Pick

Turkmenistan president fires minister over poor parenting

Turkmenistan President Gurbanguly Berdymukhamedov has fired the country's energy and industry minister at a general ministerial meeting over poor parenting skills, Turkmen television reported. President 

Partial fascism or right move - Bengal divided on Mamata's act

First a ban on certain newspapers and now the arrest of a professor for allegedly circulating a cartoon targeting Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee. Is it "a move towards censorship and partial fascism" by the state government 

Hindu groups upset over Chandy for giving IUML fifth ministership

Kerala Chief Minister Oommen Chandy has come under fire from Hindu social groups besides his own Congress party ever since he gave a fifth ministership to his second biggest ally, the Indian Union Muslim League 


Picture of the Day

Bollywood star Shah Rukh Khan with Yale Master Jeffrey Brenzel doing Bollywood dance steps.

(Photo: Michael Marsland, Yale University)



RSS  |  Contact us


| Quick links



Subscribe to

Ummid Assistant



Science & Technology



About us




Government Schemes










Contact us




    Disclaimer | Terms of Use | Advertise with us | Link Exchange is part of the Awaz Multimedia & Publications providing World News, News Analysis and Feature Articles on Education, Health. Politics, Technology, Sports, Entertainment, Industry etc. The articles or the views displayed on this website are for public information and in no way describe the editorial views. The users are entitled to use this site subject to the terms and conditions mentioned.

2010 Awaz Multimedia & Publications. All rights reserved.