Ummid Assistant

Applications open for Manmohan scholarship at Cambridge

Opportunities for Indian students in US

Welcome Guest! You are here: Home » Views & Analysis

“Vishwaroopam” and Freedom of Expression

Friday February 01, 2013 10:20:34 PM, Syed Ali Mujtaba, ummid.com

Related Article

Calm as 'Vishwaroop' releases, ban remains in Tamil Nadu

Subsequently, Kamal Haasan, who also stars in the lead role, agreed to make some cuts. Talks between his representatives and Muslim outfits have taken place in Chennai.   »

No 'bad Muslims' in my film: Kamal Haasan

Jayalalitha defends 'Vishwaroopam' ban, to sue Karunanidhi

Tamil film “Vishwaroopam” is yet another causality that’s caught in the mire of freedom of expression verses hurting people’s sentiment’s debate. Tamil Nadu government has banned the movie after some Muslim groups protested against scenes that they consider offensive. An out of court settlement is being cobbled to play out this story.
 

The tussle over what is acceptable material for movie audiences is a recurring theme in India. If the movie offends someone, it risks being unsuitable for viewing for everyone. This trend is slowly gaining currency in the country with no permanent solution in sight.
 

What is apparent is the rapidly modernizing country is unable to carry forward its largely conservative society that sees everything from the prism of caste, color, region, religion language etc.
 

One wrong move by a filmmaker and cry of hurting the sentiments is being echoed. Once such shrieks reach its crescendo the film is taken off from the cinema halls and that’s the end of the story.

Film-makers have never had it easy in India and there is a long list of movies that are banned on one pretext or other. Films like ‘DAM999’, ‘Jodhaa Akbar’, ‘Arakshan’, ‘Fire’, ‘Water’, ‘The Da Vinci Code’, ‘Black Friday’ etc, have all hit the wall with political or religious groups objecting even after making it past the censor board.
 

The Supreme Court Judgment on a similar controversy about “Ore Oru Gramathile”, a movie that was critical of the reservation policy in Tamil Nadu’s educational institutions is case in point:

“Freedom of expression cannot be suppressed on account of threat of demonstration and processions or threat of violence… it would be tantamount to negation of the rule of law and surrender to blackmail and intimidation… ”
 

Sadly, this judgment has not been all that successful in granting this right to freedom of expression. The movie ‘Dam 999’ continues to be banned in Tamil Nadu that’s about the Mullaperiyar dam issue.

The Supreme Court has declined to lift the ban stating: “The people are expecting this issue (of the Mullaperiyar dam) will be resolved. At this stage, why should we aggravate the situation not only in Tamil Nadu but also in Kerala? We can’t close our eyes to the objections and decide the case purely on legal aspects. We have to respect the sentiments of the people… The Tamil Nadu government says if the film is released, relations between the two States will be affected. When an elected government raises this issue, can the court ignore?”

The case of Vishwaroopam falls on similar category. Can a State government deploy security forces to all the cinema halls in Tamil Nadu, argues Chief Minister Jayalalitha? Will the people go to the movie theaters under the fear of the bomb blast even being protected by gun totting policemen, is another version of the argument being belted out.

Kamal Hassan has done the right thing striking a compromise with some Muslim groups objecting to the movie and has agreed to cut some scenes that they feel had hurt their sentiments.

The veteran actor argued that ultimately the release of the film was prime important to him then anything else. He ruled out moving the Supreme Court on revoking the Madras High Court order that stayed the film’s release, saying the matter is now amicably getting settled.

Kamal Hassan has bought peace with groups objecting to his movie Vishwaroopam and this has paved the way of its release, but has he done the right thing or has set a negative precedent for the future recurrence of similar issue.

Censoring movies in the name of maintaining public peace, respecting emotions of people and similar other reasons are too naïve and simplistic arguments in front of freedom of expression rights. It may give wrong message to the public and likely to be misused in the future. The best course would be to let the viewers watch the movie and form their own opinion about it.

Nonetheless, recurrence of similar issues is the point of debate. Hence, a permanent solution is essential to such problem. It is imperative to enact a new law and the court judgments on Shankarappa and Ranarajan cases can act as the bacon light in that direction.

In the prevailing circumstances, it is better to have a rating body than a Censor Board of the very nature we have at present. The most important criteria regarding such body should be that the Government can forward its suggestions/recommendations but the decision must be taken by it independently.

The power of censorship delegated to the States has to be narrowed down drastically. They must satisfy the Central authority as to why the ban in their territory is indispensable and that there is no alternative left.

In India while we enthusiastically profess right to information, we cannot sit back and ban films and censor information. Banning motion pictures is equivalent to banning the right of freedom of speech and expression.

If artists, playwrights and film makers of India are to exercise their right to free speech appropriately, the utmost necessity is to do away with the restrictive clauses under Article 19(2).

The test for allowing restrictions upon free speech should be more stringent. Legal restraints upon individual freedom of speech should only be tolerated where they are absolutely necessary to prevent infliction of actual harm. If at all, any limiting line is to be drawn in the extreme cases, it shall be left to the judiciary on which the country has enormous faith.

In sum, if democracy has to evolve, screening of films and documentaries can never be denied for reasons based on mere speculation. Some developments regarding such subject are encouraging; but others are depressing. Needless to say we still have greater heights to scale in this direction.

 


Syed Ali Mujtaba is a journalist based in Chennai. He can be contacted at sedalimujtaba@yahoo.com



 




 

Home | Top of the Page

Comments

Note: By posting your comments here you agree to the terms and conditions of www.ummid.com

Comments powered by DISQUS

i

I

More Headlines

Blast kills two outside US embassy in Turkey

Apex court prevents Nandy's arrest, advises him to speak carefully

'Textese' creeps into answer scripts, teachers worried

CARE Hospitals launch India's biggest outpatient centre

Eight firms keen to design Nalanda University

Minister raids school, teachers get the stick

On 10th death anniversary, school remembers alumna Kalpana Chawla

Rushdie not an author, is a 'satan': Trinamool MP

Diesel price to go up 40-50 paise a litre every month

New app lets users have sex with Facebook friends?

ICC Women's World Cup: India start campaign with convincing win

North Korea imposes martial law ahead of n-test

 

Top Stories

No 'bad Muslims' in my film: Kamal Haasan

Actor-filmmaker Kamal Haasan Thursday said there are no "bad Muslims" in his movie "Vishwaroopam" but added there was no way he could portray terrorists as "white" characters.  »

Jayalalitha defends 'Vishwaroopam' ban, to sue Karunanidhi

'Vishwaroopam' ban in Tamil Nadu stays

Kamal Haasan threatens to move to 'secular state abroad'

Tamil Nadu theatre fire-bombed over "Vishwaroopam" screening

 

  Most Read

Rushdie not an author, is a 'satan': Trinamool MP

Trinamool Congress MP Sultan Ahmed Friday called Salman Rushdie a "satan" and said West Bengal Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee had done the right thing if she indeed blocked the writer's visit to Kolkata.   »

Indian rights situation slips: Human Rights Watch

India's human rights situation took serious turns for the worse with respect to civil society protections and sexual violence against women, Human Rights Watch said Friday. In its 665-page World Report  »

Check rights violations in Maharashtra: Activists urge NHRC chairman

 

  News Pick

Akhtar-Zeeshan earn a rare distinction in Davis Cup

Akhtar Ali has been part of Indian tennis for five decades -- first as a player and then as a successful coach. Now his son Zeeshan is following in his footsteps, doing   »

Apex court prevents Nandy's arrest, advises him to speak carefully

The Supreme Court Friday restrained Rajasthan Police from arresting sociologist Ashis Nandy against whom FIRs have been filed for making uncharitable comments about Scheduled   »

Dhule professor beaten by Bajrang Dal, VHP activists

Angered by comments that hurt religious sentiments, local activists allegedly belonging to right wing Hindu organisations Bajrang Dal and Vishwa Hindu Parishad (VHP) on Wednesday brutally beat a college professor working at Dr Ambedkar College  »

Dhule Violence: Changing Anatomy of Communal Violence

The mob burns the houses; mostly those of Muslims, few Hindu households are also burnt. Police did not entertain any FIR of the victims. Next day morning the area is washed clean to wipe   »

 

Picture of the Day

Pradeep sings “Ae Mere Watan Ke Logon” before prime minister Jawaharlal Nehru at R.M. School, Mumbai, March 21, 1963. It is a song that is sung on every patriotic occasion, had moved India's first prime minister, Jawaharlal Nehru, to tears and its strong morale-boosting words provided solace to a nation agonized by the defeat in the 1962 India-China war.

 

Recommend the story to your friends

 

 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

RSS  |  Contact us

 

| Quick links

News

 

Subscribe to

Ummid Assistant

 

National

Science & Technology

RSS

Scholarships

About us

International

Health

Twitter

Government Schemes

Feedback

Regional

History

Facebook

Education

Register

Politics

Opinion

Newsletter

Contact us

Business

The Funny Side

Education & Career

 

 

Ummid.com: Disclaimer | Terms of Use | Advertise with us | Link Exchange

Ummid.com is part of the Awaz Multimedia & Publications providing World News, News Analysis and Feature Articles on Education, Health. Politics, Technology, Sports, Entertainment, Industry etc. The articles or the views displayed on this website are for public information and in no way describe the editorial views. The users are entitled to use this site subject to the terms and conditions mentioned.

© 2012 Awaz Multimedia & Publications. All rights reserved.