Mubarak stand: Intelligence failure or a deal gone awry?

Friday February 11, 2011 02:52:12 PM, Arun Kumar, IANS

Washington: The embattled Egyptian President Hosni Mubarak's "shocking" refusal to resign as widely anticipated has set off another round of speculation: Was it a major intelligence failure or a deal gone awry?

Or was it simply "a rare misstep" by Central Intelligence Agency (CIA) Director Leon Panetta, "who had little intelligence experience before taking the CIA job two years ago," as suggested by the Washington Post.

Panetta, it noted "helped touch off an avalanche of erroneous expectations Thursday when he testified that there was a 'strong likelihood' that Mubarak would step down by the end of the day."

Within minutes, senior aides to Panetta sought to tamp down the impact, saying he was merely referring to media reports, the Post said.

"But by then, the comments had ricocheted around the internet, underscoring US confusion about events unfolding in Egypt, as well as the perils of publicly weighing in on such developments while serving as director of CIA."

The explanation that Panetta was citing news accounts protected him from being on the hook if the prediction turned out not to be true, the Post said.

"But it also carried a more subtle public relations risk, suggesting that the CIA chief was not necessarily any better informed than others at Thursday's hearing, scanning their cell phones for breaking news," it said.

"His statements were not based on intelligence reports," an unnamed senior US intelligence official was quoted as saying by the Post. And "i would be wrong for anyone to suggest that the CIA didn't get things right on Egypt."

Director of National Intelligence James R. Clapper Jr. also defended the intelligence community Thursday saying that spy services have produced thousands of reports in recent years warning of instability in Egypt and elsewhere in the Middle East.

But he acknowledged that it was unclear what events might trigger a government overthrow. "I would give it at least a B-plus, not an A-minus," said Clapper as cited by the Post.

Panetta also acknowledged that the agency needs to do a better job of spotting specific vulnerabilities for governments and of monitoring the Internet's role in fomenting protests.

But apparently everyone took Panetta's comments at face value. "All indications were that Mubarak would step down," noted intelligence think tank Stratfor analyst Reva Bhalla.

"That was the message transmitted in Washington with ... Panetta telling Congress he has heard that Mubarak would step down. Somewhere along the line that understanding unravelled," she said.

(Arun Kumar can be contacted at arun.kumar@ians.in)

                                           Home | Top of the Page

Top Stories

Mubarak addresses nation, says no plan to step down

A defiant Hosni Mubarak Thursday announced that he would transfer some powers to his deputy Omar Suleiman, but stopped short of resigning as president of Egypt. He said he will not bow to foreign pressure.  »

Tahrir Square in festive mood as speculation swirls of Mubarak leaving

Tonight, it is ending, says Egyptian army chief

Strong likelihood of Mubarak stepping down: CIA director

  Most Read

Controversial 'Kumbh' focusing on conversion begins in Madhya Pradesh

A different kind of Mahakumbh began in Mandla in Madhya Pradesh Thursday. Unlike the rituals    »

RSS ‘Kumbh’ in MP: Petrified Christians fear Kandhamal-like situation

Law giving voting rights to NRIs comes into force

Non-resident Indians can now get their names registered in the electoral rolls, with the amended legislation coming into force Thursday. A press release by the law and justice ministry Thursday said th    »

'Demand to vote by NRIs driven by desire to contest elections'

  News Pick

Finding SSC exams difficult to crack? At Iqra, it is made easy

Come January and the biggest challenge that the parents of the +10 students face is to keep them at ease so that they not only    »

Ex-Kerala minister, two  others get jail term for corruption

The Supreme Court Thursday sentenced former Congress minister from Kerala R. Balakrishna Pillai and two others to one-year jail for corruption in the award of contract for a hydro-power project. Pillai said he would go   »

Comments on President cost Rajasthan minister his job

Rajasthan minister Amin Khan, who remarked that Pratibha Patil was made president for having cooked in late former prime minister Indira Gandhi's kitchen, has been asked to resign. Chief Minister Ashok Gehlot late   »

Refused phone number, trooper kills woman kabaddi player

Manisha Kumari, a woman kabaddi player, was shot dead by a CRPF trooper posted at a Patna stadium where she had been practicing for the 34th National Games when she refused to give him her phone number, police   »

Chhattisgarh high court dismisses Binayak Sen's bail plea

The Chhattisgarh High Court Thursday dismissed the bail application of human rights activist Binayak Sen,  »

Sen's wife, friends shaken by rejection of bail plea