Combative Manmohan refutes opposition charges of buying MPs

Wednesday March 23, 2011 08:32:38 PM, IANS

New Delhi: The political rift in parliament widened Wednesday with the opposition launching a stinging attack against Manmohan Singh for citing the 2009 electoral victory to defend allegations that the Congress bought MPs to win the 2008 trust vote and the prime minister reiterating that his government was not involved in any "illegal act".

An unusually combative Manmohan Singh castigated the opposition and rejected the "wild" charges of bribery after the Left and the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) attacked him for his not-guilty statement in the US diplomatic cables leaked by WikiLeaks and published by The Hindu newspaper.

The prime minister had in his March 18 statement refuted the charges made in the "speculative, unverified and unverifiable" diplomatic communications and said the people had rejected the bribery allegations by returning his government to power in the 2009 elections.

Referring to the a parliamentary committee probe into what came to be known as "cash-for-votes" scam, Manmohan Singh said Wednesday the panel had concluded that there was "insufficient evidence" to prove that MPs were purchased to save the government from falling in 2008.

"I am convinced that taking the report as a whole, this is a correct inference," Manmohan Singh said in reply to a heated debate in the Lok Sabha. He made an identical statement in the Rajya Sabha.

He said he was leaving "it to the good sense of this house to decide whether the report of the committee in any way substantiates the wild allegations".

Amid thumping of desks by MP's of the Congress and alliance partners, an animated prime minister, with a smile on his face, said it was "not for the first time" he was facing the wrath of the opposition. "I have had to go through that as finance minister and as prime minister. The main opposition, right from 2004, adopted the attitude that we are a usurper."

Manmohan Singh also took a dig at his known bitter critic, veteran Bharatiya Janata Party leader L.K. Advani who often accuses him of being the weakest prime minister.

"Advaniji believes that prime ministership is his birthright. He has not forgiven me. All I can say to Advaniji is that the people of India have voted us to power in free and fair elections. Please wait for another three-and-a-half years." Advani merely smiled.

As the opposition MPs heard him silently, the ruling benches echoed with loud thumping of desks and peals of laughter. Congress president Sonia Gandhi and Finance Minister Pranab Mukherjee were seen smiling and nodding their heads in agreement.

The prime minister's pointed reaction came after the BJP and the Left parties attacked him for his not-guilty statement made on March 18 following the WikiLeaks expose and accused him of concealing facts.

Leader of Opposition Sushma Swaraj, citing the 1984 anti-Sikh riots and the 2002 sectarian violence in Gujarat, said Manmohan Singh was rewriting criminal jurisprudence by bringing in the electoral victory to defend his government.

Attacking the prime minister, the BJP leader asked him if he was willing to apply the same yardstick to Gujarat Chief Minister Narendra Modi for the 2002 anti-Muslim riots in that state.

"Election victory or defeat cannot wipe away any crime. The episode has shamed India. It has blemished our democratic tradition," she said and recited an Urdu couplet questioning the prime minister's deflecting defence and his leadership qualities.

"Tu idhar udhar ki na baat kar, yeh bata ki qaafila kyon loota; hamein rahzanon se gila nahin, teri rehbari ka sawaal hai." (Don't talk hearsay, tell us why the caravan was looted; we have no grouse against dacoits but it is a question of your leadership).

Injecting humour into the otherwise hostile proceedings Manmohan Singh turned on the wit to reply in the same coin: "Maana ki teri deed ke qaabil nahin hoon main; too mera shouq tou dekh, mera intezaar tou dekh." (I understand that I am not worth your gaze; but have a look at my keenness, have a look at my anticipation for you)."

Communist Party of India (CPI) Lok Sabha leader Gurudas Dasgupta, who initiated the debate, said the prime minister's justification of highlighting the electoral victory after the 2008 episode "cannot hide criminality if it has been committed".

The upper house also witnessed an early afternoon debate that was less noisy than the animated one in the lower house.

Sushma Swaraj's Rajya Sabha counterpart Arun Jaitley and Home Minister P. Chidambaram exchanged heated arguments.

Jaitley said: "If the government of India wants to verify and you have honesty of purpose, they are verifiable because some of the evidence is very strong evidence in a criminal case of bribe-giver." He alleged that the shortfall in members during the trust vote was covered by "retail purchase of parliamentarians".

                                           Home | Top of the Page

Top Stories

Narendra Modi unapologetic on the Gujarat carnage: US Diplomat

In a comment that can hamper Narendra Modi's image building campaign, US Consul General Michael S. Owen, in a released US cable   »

Tackle US meddling in India: Narendra Modi

 Indian PM seems to be misleading public on cables: WikiLeaks chief

  Most Read

Gaddafi appears in public, vows to fight on

Libyan leader Muammar Gaddafi made a public appearance near Tripoli, vowing to fight on, as the Western countries led by   »

'Gaddafi's daughter Aisha is Claudia Schiffer of North Africa'

Opposition slams PM for statement on WikiLeaks revelations

The Left and the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) Wednesday attacked Prime Minister Manmohan Singh for his not-guilty statement following allegations that the Congress had bought MPs in the 2008 trust vote and accused him of   »

Advaniji has not forgiven me for becoming PM: Manmohan

  News Pick

Lack of experts, no regulatory authority hinder growth of Islamic Finance

Acknowledging that the Islamic Finance can play a very important role for the recession-ridden world, economists and bankers gathered at Jeddah Economi   »

Court admits CBI plea to extradite Anderson

A Delhi court Wednesday allowed the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) plea seeking extradition of Warren Anderson, the 90-year-old US-based former Union Carbide chief, for the 1984 .  »

Students' stir disrupts exams in Aligarh university

All important activities in the Aligarh Muslim University (AMU), including admissions and examinations, remained paralyzed Tuesday on account of the forced locking of the central offices by the students' union a day earlier.  »

Make eighth chapter of Telangana report public: high court

The Andhra Pradesh High Court Wednesday directed the central government to make public the eighth chapter of the Justice Srikrishna Committee report on the issue of statehood   »

Eight including children killed in Israeli airstrikes in Gaza

At least eight Palestinians, including children, have been killed in mortar attacks and airstrikes in the Gaza Strip. The deaths occurred in two separate attacks on the eastern part of Gaza City on Tuesday, witnesses  »

Picture of the Day

President of India Mrs. Pratibha Devisingh Patil addressing at the inauguration of the National Festival of Tribal Dances, ‘PRAKRITI’, in New Delhi on March 16, 2011. Union Minister for Housing and Urban Poverty Alleviation and Culture, Kum. Selja, Union Minister for Tribal Affairs Kantilal Bhuria and Minister of State for Tribal Affairs Mahadev S. Khandela are also seen.

(Photo: Mukesh Kumar)