Ummid Assistant

Samsung sets up fund for poor kids' education

US varsity offers doctorate for education professionals

Welcome Guest! You are here: Home » Views & Analysis

Caught in Crossfire - Dinesh Trivedi

Monday March 26, 2012 03:09:21 PM, Syed Ali Mujtaba,

Related Articles

Dinesh Trivedi finally bows, agrees to quit

Ending days of stalemate, Railway Minister Dinesh Trivedi Sunday agreed to quit after speaking with his Trinamool Congress party chief Mamata Banerjee,   »

Dinesh Trivedi sows dissent in Trinamool ranks

Trinamool asks Trivedi to go, he wants Mamata's written order

Angry Mamata tells PM to replace Trivedi by Mukul Roy

Amid bedlam, Govt. gets some relief, courtesy allies

The ugly face of coalition politics came into open when Dinesh Trivedi, the Union Railway Minister representing the Trinamool Congress, was made to resign after presenting his maiden budget.

Trivedi presented the annual rail budget on 14 March 2012. The budget included an all over hike in passenger fares, ranging from 2 paise to 30 paise per kilometer for reasons of safety along with network expansion and modernization of the Railways.

The rail budget was appreciated by the general public, industry groups and all five Rail Unions of the country.

The only person who disapproved the budget was the Trivedi’s own part chief Ms Mamata Banerjee. The Chief Minister of West Bengal declared that she was not consulted on railway fare hike as proposed in the budget.

Ms Banerjee demanded the withdrawal of the proposal and also the dismissal of Railway Minister Dinesh Trived, her party nominee.

It was amidst high drama that Trivedi finally resigned on March, 18, 2012, being the first railway minister of the country who has removed for serving the railways.

Indian Railways is the country's largest employer and there are about 14 lakh employees. The annual plan for 2012-13 has been set for Rs.60,100 crore, hardly 10 per cent more than last year. The Union government’s budgetary support is restricted to Rs.24,000 crore.

Now how the deficit funds has to be raised. Naturally, the Railways have to augment its own internal resources. This is what exactly Trivedi did.

Its through a rationalization of the freight tariff he propose to garner Rs.20,000 crore. He advocated revision of the present fare that was not touched for eight years and that would fetch an additional Rs.7,000 crore.

Trivedi did not touch the sleeper class fare but only proposed the revision of the first class or air-conditioned class fares.

However, this became his achelies heel. The Minister was forced to resign for showing loyalty to the country and its Railways then to his own party.

It’s for long Indian Railways has been victim of populism of successive Railway Ministers starting from Ram Vilas Paswan, Lalu Prasad Yadav and Mamata Banerjee.

Had the Railway gone in for a marginal three to five-per-cent revision in fares over the years, the hefty increase in upper class rail fare that Trivedi proposed may not have been necessary?

In all honesty of purpose the minister did what were good the country and railways. As the Railway minister, Trivedi advocated instituting a rail regulator to fix rail fares.

He has also advocated de-politicizing the Railways and would like to restructure the Indian Railway Board.

Trivedi believed that the Indian Railways can add 2% to India's GDP. However, for that the government must modernize the railways and for doing that needed adequate funds.

He also sounded open to the idea of privatization of the Railways, which would allow more funds to be allocated to help the system cope with capacity.

Trivedi also expressed his interest to start high speed passenger trains in India with Japanese help or French support.

As a matter of fact, he tried to push for a national policy on railways that would continue irrespective of political changes in the government.

All this did not go down well with his political party, the Trinamool Congress, in particular Ms Mamta Banerjee, the West Bengal Chief Minister. She made fare hike an issue and Dinesh Trivedi a scapegoat.

The TMC and the Congress party were having uneasy relationship for some time. The drama centered on Dinesh Trivedi was an act of arms twisting by the TMC to demonstrate that an alliance partner can call the shots, even in a legitimate case.

As a cabinet minister in Manmohan Singh’s cabinet, Dinesh Trivedi was serving the Indian nation and not the Trinamool Congress. The Rail Budget he prepared was at the instruction of the Prime Minister of India and not to suit the whim and fancy of his party high command.

This is where he was caught off guard. The Trinamool Chief, Mnamata Banerjee took this as an offence as to why its nominee did not follow the party policy of no increase in rail fares and went by the instruction of the union government.

It sounds bizarre but indeed true that on this issue the TMC gunned for Trivedi’s portfolio. What a very sad commentary on the functioning of the Indian democracy.

The fare hike issue could have been amicably settled between the UPA and the TMC with an agreement of partial roll back without disturbing Dinesh Trivedi.

But given the unpredictable nature of the TMC leader Ms Mamata Banerjee, the matter was to be resolved only through the resignation of the railway minister. In such case Trivedi for no fault, had to resign for the sake of coalition dharma.

For the UPA, this TMC drama comes as another crisis in an already difficult situation. It could no way have got out of this mess without pandering to its wish. For it crisis management was more important then individual and right policies.

Dinesh Trivedi episode is certainly an unfortunate development and a sad commentary on the working of world’s largest democracy.


Syed Ali Mujtaba is journalist based in Chennai. He can be contacted at



Home | Top of the Page


Note: By posting your comments here you agree to the terms and conditions of

Comments powered by DISQUS






Top Stories

About 70 percent of India is poor: Top adviser

Debunking the government's claim that the number of poor in India has come down, a top adviser has claimed that around 70 percent of the country's 1.2 billion population is poor, and stressed the need for a   »

'Childhood poverty remains a reality in India

People Without History: India's Muslim Ghettos


  Most Read

Anna returns with anti-graft protest, threatens more agitation

Anna Hazare, on a day-long fast Sunday, set a 2014 deadline -- when general elections are scheduled -- for an all-powerful anti-corruption watchdog and threatened to launch a court arrest  »

Maoists release one abducted Italian

State Home Secretary U.N. Behera said the rebels released Claudio Colangelo. "His health is apparently fine," Behera told IANS. The government will continue efforts to secure the release of the other Italian, Bosusco Paolo, and a Biju Janata Dal  »

Odisha talks halted as Maoists seize legislator


  News Pick

Now fire in Bengal bus depot, minister says sabotage

Kolkata continued to play with fire when the record room of the West Bengal government-run Calcutta State Transport Corporation (CSTC) was destroyed by a blaze Sunday. A state minister later called it a case of sabotage.  »

Rescue the dying Yamuna to save the Taj, appeal activists

Hundreds of activists, students and senior citizens walked along the banks of the bone-dry river Yamuna in Agra Sunday in a symbolic  »

Tension at Telangana student's funeral procession

The suicide of a student for separate statehood to Telangana has brought the issue back into focus with a shutdown being observed Sunday in Warangal district amid tension and some groups  »


Picture of the Day

Prime Minister Dr. Manmohan Singh releasing a book entitled “Hundred Years”, at the Oxford University Press Centenary Celebrations, in New Delhi on March 21 2012. Vice Chancellor University of Oxford Prof. Andrew Hamilton is also seen.

(Photo: Mukesh



RSS  |  Contact us


| Quick links



Subscribe to

Ummid Assistant



Science & Technology



About us




Government Schemes










Contact us




    Disclaimer | Terms of Use | Advertise with us | Link Exchange is part of the Awaz Multimedia & Publications providing World News, News Analysis and Feature Articles on Education, Health. Politics, Technology, Sports, Entertainment, Industry etc. The articles or the views displayed on this website are for public information and in no way describe the editorial views. The users are entitled to use this site subject to the terms and conditions mentioned.

© 2010 Awaz Multimedia & Publications. All rights reserved.