Ummid Assistant

Taj Group to train underprivileged rural youth in Maharashtra

Robotics competition for Andhra school students

Welcome Guest! You are here: Home » Views & Analysis

The Choice in this forthcoming General Election

Friday May 03, 2013 12:06:19 AM, Irfan Engineer

In the run upto the general elections, the campaign issues of the two major national parties are becoming clearer and sharper, as also acrimonious statements. The BJP’s campaign always has been – India is an ancient nation-civilization; that its vitality was lost due to invasions; that Congress is unable to restore the nation to its past glory as it emulates the west and continues with the institutional structures of British era; that the “civilizational consciousness” which makes India one country, one people and one nation, which the Congress cannot restore and the civilizational consciousness is well defined by the sages and philosophers and which has its roots in Hindu world view (read upper caste); that the Congress appeases the minority for vote bank politics; that it is soft on Pakistan for the same reason; that Congress does not sabre rattle and bully its South Asian neighbours enough and plays ball with Pakistan; that large numbers of Bangladeshis are allowed to “infiltrate” into India from its eastern borders and even carryout terrorist acts; that Congress’ weakness had compromised the internal security; that Congress is unable to tackle separatism and terrorism, including Maoist terrorism, with firmness; and finally, the Congress will be unable to pull out the country from the slow economic growth, and therefore poverty, inflation, etc. In its manifesto for the 2009 Lok Sabha elections, the BJP states “What was required after independence was to reorient India’s polity to bring it in consonance with the seekings and sensibilities of the Indian people” (read upper caste Hindus). “Failure to do so has resulted in a fractured society, vast economic disparities, terrorism and communal conflict, insecurity, moral, psychological and spiritual degradation, and a state apparatus unable to handle any of these problems.” Corruption will be an additional issue exploited by the BJP in the general elections.

Hindu Rashtra, Integral Humanism

and Hindu Civilizational Consciousness
Though the diagnosis of BJP seems to identify Congress as centre of all ills facing the nation, Congress is blamed only for limited purpose of election. If one reads BJP’s election manifestoes carefully, Congress is blamed for a limited purpose - being vehicle for the ills that afflict the nation. Congress in the conception of the BJP is not the cause of the ills that afflict Hindu Rashtra. Establishment of Hindu Rashtra – the ideological goal of the BJP – is not checked or obstructed by Congress, and Congress therefore may be a competitor in elections and therefore needs to be targeted during elections, however, it is not an enemy of Hindu Rashtra. Hindu Rashtra has three declared enemies – Muslims, Christians, Communists and the western notion of citizenship and human rights, particularly, the notion of equality. Citizenship, human rights and equality are against the “Hindu” civilizational consciousness as defined by the sages.

The Hindu civilizational consciousness is that of caste based hierarchy which considers the dalits as untouchables less than even animals as animals can be touched and some are even worshiped. Similarly, “Hindu” civilizational consciousness of ancient sages deprived women of their rights and human dignity and treated them to be chattels to be owned by their father in the first instance and after marriage by their husbands. Congress is the tool for the Muslims and Christians to claim citizenship rights. “From time to time, Congressmen have declared welfare state, socialism, liberalism etc. as their aims” laments Deendayal Upadhyay, former President of Bharatiya Jan Sangh – the earlier version of BJP – in one of his lectures.

BJP subscribes to Hindu Rashtra and Deendayal Upadhyay’s thesis of Integral Humanism. Integral Humanism terms the “social contract theory” as fundamentally incorrect. The theory views the norms and laws of collective society as implied agreement between the individuals. “It is true that the society is composed of a number of individuals. Yet it is not made by people, nor does it come into being by mere coming together of a number of individuals. In our view society is self-born.” Integral Humanism compares society to the Virat-purusha: “In our concept of four castes, they are thought of as analogous to the different limbs of Virat-purusha. It was suggested that from the head of the Virat-Purusha Bhrahmins were created, Kshatriyas from hands, Vaishyas from his abdomen and Shudras from legs. If we analyze this concept we are faced with the question whether there can arise any conflict among the head, arms. [S]tomach and legs of the same Virat Purusha. If conflict is fundamental, the body cannot be maintained. There cannot be any conflict in the different parts of the same body. On the contrary "one man" prevails. These limbs are not only complementary to one another, but even further, there is individual unity. There is a complete identity of interest identity of belonging. The origin of the caste system was on the above basis.” What appears to Deendayal Upadhyay as self-born society (and therefore natural) is a harmonious caste-based hierarchy with birth-based division of occupations – some enjoying the privileges while others confined to performing duties and menial work. This apportioning of privileges and duties among different section of society is based on coercion and force and is not self-born or natural. The use of force and coercion reflects even in the Epics of Ramayana and Mahabharata which Deendayal fails to take note of before declaring it to be self-born – cutting off the thumb of Eklavya; killing of Shambhuk for reciting Vedas, Sita’s trial by fire etc. But the purpose behind decrying liberty and dignity of individuals and the “social contract theory”, is to approve absolute subjugation of individuals to the “self-born” society in which all the sections of the society – viz. castes – live harmoniously without producing any conflict or without challenging natural and self-born but oppressive collective. Everybody needs to accept order, howsoever hierarchical and howsoever oppressive only for the sake of harmony because individuals have no agency – are only supposed to be subservient for the sake of society and in fact, exist only for the sake of the “nation”.

The State, for the BJP, is subservient to the nation, brought into existence to protect the nation, i.e. produce and maintain conditions in which the ideals of the nation can be translated into reality. Integral humanism terms the ideals of the nation as "Chiti", which is analogous to the soul of an individual. According to Deendayal, the laws that help manifest and maintain Chiti of a Nation are termed Dharma of that nation and it is this "Dharma" that is supreme. Anyone who abandons Dharma betrays the nation. The Chiti, or Hindu civilizational consciousness or Dharma that has survived over centuries – in spite of foreign aggression is caste hierarchies and caste structured society. It is through khap panchayats that the Dharma or chiti or civilizational consciousness of the nation survived over centuries and therefore it is eternal. BJP’s integral humanism propounds, that it is not the majority of people who decide what is good for them it is Dharma that decides what is good for people and therefore not democracy, not “Jana Rajya” but Dharma Rajya that is desired and the State has to sub-serve the nation by upholding Dharma (caste based) Rajya. So fundamental is the caste system to the BJP’s doctrine of Integral Humanism and the “civilizational consciousness” that neither the nation-state nor the majority of people can be trusted with it, indeed not the democratic state with liberalism or socialism or individual dignity or human rights. The “chiti” vests in a small coterie that will need the help of a militarized and authoritarian state to enforce it and all that the majority of the people need to do is to submit to this coterie else suffer oppressive and violent consequence. This is why Muslims, Christians and Communism are perceived as enemies of Hindu Rashtra they would not accept their religious consciousness would not accept the “Dharma” that integral humanism propounds, as the concept of equality is at the core of their religious consciousness, even though not a social reality.

The Congress Party
The Congress party perseveres to build the charisma of Rahul Gandhi, carefully and selectively fielding him for public events. Rahul Gandhi himself pretends to be a reluctant candidate who is more interested in bringing about change with the help of team Congress as against, ‘a man charging on a horse solving nation’s problems’. The Congress party is using or rather misusing the slogan of secularism to isolate the BJP from at least some of the NDA allies and scare away potential allies. The slogan of secularism is also handy to mobilize the minorities to electoral booths. To the industrialist, the Congress is promising reforms, albeit at a slow pace. To the marginalized sections like the adivasis and the dalits, whose votes it endeavours to mobilize, a few sops and poorly funded schemes that are even more poorly implemented to benefit the targeted group. Rahul Gandhi used the metaphor of beehive. The metaphor is apt as ordinary Indians work hard to help the country reach high growth rates only so that the honey of their labour and the natural resources of the country is slurped and polished off by the crony capitalist class. The Congress is more of a status-quoist party ushering pro-capital economic reforms in calibrated measures facilitating more and more influx and more or less free movement of foreign capital in order to maximize returns.

We should not mistake the contest between the BJP led NDA and Congress led UPA as that between two equally bad or corrupt political alliances or more those having more or less same economic programmes. The contest between UPA and NDA is not between a corrupt and an honest party, nor between a minority appeaser and pseudo secular vs. truly secular party nor between development with human face and development on horseback – it is between two world views – hierarchically structured social system of Dharma enforced by totalitarian state or liberal values of liberty, equality and fraternity, for human dignity of all! Survival of democracy is at stake.

There are three issues that are creating conducive environment for the totalitarian forces to take over – 1) the economy of the country has slowed down due to its excessive dependence on exports after liberalization and on account of the economic crisis in Europe and US; 2) the media has been focusing almost exclusively on the issues of corruption since about last two years, if not more creating an impression of chaos and non-functional democracy and 3) perceived existence of an external enemy due to constant belligerence and sabre rattling on the borders with Pakistan is stoking feelings of worst form of jingoism and chauvinistic nationalism among the urban middle-class which has benefitted from globalization. The opposition is trying its best to obstruct the functioning of Parliament on one pretext or the other to escalate the chaos and demonstrate impotency of democracy and democratic institutions. This situation is leading the common man, particularly the urban middle-class, and to feel helpless and demand a strong authoritarian state. The communal forces have an authoritarian ideology just for the situation where people lose faith in democracy! The situation needs only one more factor for imposing a totalitarian regime on the basis of “Dharma” a theocratic state – a mass leader with charismatic qualities. That mass leader is being built up by the media and the industrial-capitalist class in the form of Narendra Modi.

It is upto the electorate to make their choice






Home | Top of the Page


Note: By posting your comments here you agree to the terms and conditions of

Comments powered by DISQUS


More Headlines

SARS like virus takes five more deaths in Saudi Arabia

Khurshid to go ahead with Beijing visit: Official

All-party meet to show EVMs with verifiable vote, apex court told

Experts to reconstruct Ghaziabad 'custody death' scene

Indian workers in Saudi Arabia can regularise visa status

No evidence to link Sarabjit attack to Afzal hanging: Najam Sethi

Gandhi's prayer beads, letters to go under hammer in UK

SC directs CBSE to hold supplementary NEET for Urdu medium students

Court orders NIA to release Rs.2.6mn it seized from 'suspect'


Top Stories

India Pakistan

Sarabjit's body arrives in India; state funeral Friday

Indian death row prisoner Sarabjit Singh's body was brought to India after he died in a Pakistani hospital early Thursday, succumbing to his injuries six days after being attacked by his fellow inmates in a jail and pushing the  »

Special aircraft to bring back Sarabjit's body

Sarabjit Singh dies in Lahore hospital


  Most Read

SC directs CBSE to hold supplementary NEET for Urdu medium students

Providing a timely relief to hundreds of Urdu medium students, the Supreme Court of India in a historic decision on Thursday directed the Central Board of Secondary Education (CBSE) to hold  »

Framing Innocents

Court orders NIA to release Rs.2.6mn it seized from 'suspect'

The National Investigation Agency (NIA) Special Court in New Delhi on Thursday ordered the country's central investigating agency to release over 2.6 million rupees in cash it seized from the residence of a "suspect" during  »


  News Pick

SC dismisses challenge to FDI in multi-brand retail

"Consumer is the king", the Supreme Court said Wednesday upholding the government's policy of allowing foreign direct investment (FDI) in multi-brand retail  »

US Visa Ban

US religious body concerned over Modi entry into US

A US federal advisory body has reiterated its concerns about Gujarat Chief Minister Narendra Modi's admissibility to the US due to his alleged "complicity in the 2002 riots" in the state.  »

Madhya Pradesh Chief Minister lays foundation stone of Bhopal Haj House

The long cherished dreams of Muslims of having a Hajj House at Bhopal was fulfilled when its foundation stone laying ceremony was performed here at Singarcholi near the city’s airport with much religious fervour. Muslims from all over the state in large numbers converged  »

1 killed as quake on Himachal-J&K border rocks north India

One person was killed and tremors were felt in the Indian capital and large parts of north India, including Srinagar, Jammu, Shimla and Chandigarh, following a 5.8-magnitude quake  »


Picture of the Day

A view of the newly Commissioned Indian Coast Guard Ship H-191, in Mumbai Harbour on April 09, 2013.


Recommend the story to your friends



RSS  |  Contact us


| Quick links



Subscribe to

Ummid Assistant



Science & Technology



About us




Government Schemes










Contact us


The Funny Side

Education & Career Disclaimer | Terms of Use | Advertise with us | Link Exchange is part of the Awaz Multimedia & Publications providing World News, News Analysis and Feature Articles on Education, Health. Politics, Technology, Sports, Entertainment, Industry etc. The articles or the views displayed on this website are for public information and in no way describe the editorial views. The users are entitled to use this site subject to the terms and conditions mentioned.

© 2012 Awaz Multimedia & Publications. All rights reserved.