Ummid Assistant

Taj Group to train underprivileged rural youth in Maharashtra

Robotics competition for Andhra school students

Welcome Guest! You are here: Home » National

Law minister , PMO made changes in coal report, CBI tells SC

Monday May 06, 2013 08:45:06 PM, IANS

Related Article

Coal Block

Government battles crisis after court slap over coal mess

UPA II battled a crisis Tuesday after the Supreme Court censured the Manmohan Singh government for meddling in the CBI investigation into coal  »

Harin Raval resigns as additional solicitor general

SC for liberating CBI from government interference


New Delhi: The CBI told the Supreme Court Monday that at the instance of Law and Justice Minister Ashwani Kumar four changes were made in its draft report on the probe into coal blocks allocation but no evidence against any suspect was removed.

In a nine-page affidavit, Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) Director Ranjit Sinha said that "there was no deletion of any evidence against any suspect" and the "central theme of the status report" was "not changed".

Sinha said the CBI's tentative findings that the screening committee which scrutinised applications for the allocation of coal blocks had not prepared a broadsheet or chart for its evaluation was deleted at the instance of Ashwani Kumar from the draft report.

"The other tentative findings about non-preparation of broadsheets or charts by the screening committee, to the best of our recollection, was deleted by the union minister of law and justice (Ashwani Kumar)," Sinha said in the affidavit, filed in pursuance to the apex court's April 30 order.

It said at the instance of the minister a sentence was deleted about the scope of the inquiry with respect to the legality of the allocations.

Sinha said at the instance of the officials of the coal ministry and the Prime Minister's Office (PMO), its "tentative findings about the non-existence of a system regarding allocation of specific weightage/points was deleted..." from the draft status report based on its preliminary enquiry 2 (PE 2) concerning allocations made during 2006-09.

The affidavit said the changes were made in the final status report pertaining to its preliminary inquiry about the non-existence of approved guidelines for the allocation of coal blocks.

Pointing to the four changes made at the instance of Ashwani Kumar and officials of the PMO and the coal ministry, the affidavit said: "The central theme of the status report had not changed post-meetings. There was no deletion of any evidence against any suspect or accused, nor were any let off."

Submitting that it had no intention of holding back any report from the government or suppress any information, the affidavit by Sinha said that in the absence of no specific direction on the issue by court "it did not occur to us" that the facts ought to be brought to its notice.

Leaving former additional solicitor general Haren Raval to fend for himself, the affidavit said that he had no instructions from the CBI to tell the court that the draft status report was not shared with anybody except the court.

Raval's statement that the March 8 status report had not been shared with any one and was "meant only for the court" was not made on the instructions of the CBI, Sinha said.

The CBI director's affidavit contradicted Attorney General G.E Vahanvati's repeated assertion that he had not seen the status report.

"On the same day in the afternoon on the receipt of a message from Raval, CBI Joint Director O.P. Galhotra and DIG Ravikant went to the residence of Vahanvati, where Raval too was present. Vahanvati glanced through the status report of PE 2 and PE 4," the affidavit said.

"He (Vahanvati) made certain observations which were explained to him. He also suggested certain minor changes in the status report of PE 2. The attorney general neither asked for nor was given a copy of the final status reports that were submitted before the (apex) Court," the affidavit read.

Sinha recalled the sequence of meetings and said no minutes were prepared after the meetings between its officers and the officials of the PMO, coal ministry and the law officers.

Therefire, the facts stated in the affidavit were based on the best recollection of "my memory and of my officers," Sinha said.

The CBI director told the court that there was nothing in the CBI (crime) manual to guide whether status reports in respect of on-going investigations in sub-judice matters were to be shared with others.

He said the departmental circulars and government instructions, too, were silent on this count.






Home | Top of the Page


Note: By posting your comments here you agree to the terms and conditions of

Comments powered by DISQUS


More Headlines

BSE to offer courses in UAE to help boost financial market

Pakistani envoy sees 'critical' prisoner, seeks impartial probe

First Muslim from Maharashtra's tribal district makes it to civil services

Third generation Sikh paddler a rising Kiwi talent

SC nod for Kudankulam n-plant but people's protest to continue

Row erupts over unveiling NTR's statue in parliament

India to have five rocket launches, including Mars mission, in 2013

Woman delivers twins on train - for the second time!

Syria deploys missile defence batteries towards Israel

Two days after blast, UP Chief Minister visits Nadwatul Ulema


Top Stories

Karnataka Polls

69 percent voting in near peaceful election

Around 69 percent voting was registered Sunday in the 14th Karnataka legislative assembly election in 223 constituencies, with heavy turnout in rural   »

Congress looks likely to win Karnataka, BJP suffer massive defeat: Exit polls

Hundreds of voters boycott polling in Karnataka


  Most Read

Chinese Incursion

India, China end border stand-off ahead of Khurshid visit

India and China Sunday ended the 20-day-old border stand-off by agreeing to pull back their troops to their respective positions prior to April 15 -- when Chinese troops. »

Middle East Conflict

Israeli air-strikes on Syria continues for second day

Syria's residents were startled by heavy blasts that shook Damascus early Sunday when Israeli warplanes targeted a military research center in the capital’s  »

Israeli attack opens door to all eventualities: Syria


  News Pick

Muslim Vote

Hindutva leaders can guarantee Muslim security: Uma Bharti

Only right-wing Hindutva leaders can guarantee the security of Muslims in India, BJP leader Uma Bharti said Sunday, as she defended Gujarat Chief Minister Narendra  »

Google uses tagline as 'Palestine'; Israel fumes

Internet search engine Google has taken a small but politically loaded step by changing the tagline on the homepage of its Palestinian version from “Palestinian Territories” to “Palestine.” The move has surprised rival Israel.  »

First kidney transplant from dead donor in UAE

In a landmark surgery in the UAE, a hospital carried out a kidney transfer and transplant from a deceased donor from Saudi Arabia to a 23-year-old woman patient from Abu Dhabi. The surgery was done at the Sheikh  »

Now a Shariah Index for financial inclusion of Indian Muslims

Last month, the BSE Institute, a wholly owned subsidiary of the exchange, in association with Taqwaa Advisory and Shariah Investment Solution  »


Picture of the Day

A view of the newly Commissioned Indian Coast Guard Ship H-191, in Mumbai Harbour on April 09, 2013.


Recommend the story to your friends



RSS  |  Contact us


| Quick links



Subscribe to

Ummid Assistant



Science & Technology



About us




Government Schemes










Contact us


The Funny Side

Education & Career Disclaimer | Terms of Use | Advertise with us | Link Exchange is part of the Awaz Multimedia & Publications providing World News, News Analysis and Feature Articles on Education, Health. Politics, Technology, Sports, Entertainment, Industry etc. The articles or the views displayed on this website are for public information and in no way describe the editorial views. The users are entitled to use this site subject to the terms and conditions mentioned.

© 2012 Awaz Multimedia & Publications. All rights reserved.