New Delhi: The central government might have got the contentious land acquisition bill cleared in the Lok Sabha, but activists on Wednesday described the amendments therein as "mere cosmetic" changes. The industry, however, welcomed the bill.
The new bill seeks to replaces an ordinance promulgated in December last year which had amended certain provisions of the 2013 act passed during the UPA rule.
The key points which were removed from the earlier law related to the consent clause and the social impact assessment study.
The consent clause provided for 70-80 percent of those dependent on the land to agree to its acquisition and the social impact assessment clause entailed carrying out a study to see the environmental impact and rehabilitation of people displaced.
The central government effected nine fresh amendments in the bill passed on Tuesday, but activists say none of them addresses these basic concerns.
"The amendments do not address the key concerns of doing away of the consent clause and the social impact assessment study," Madhuresh Kumar, national convenor of the National Alliance of People's Movements, told IANS.
Some of the amendments added like compulsory employment to one member of a farm labourer's family were already there in the original act, he claimed, adding that "nothing has been addressed".
According to P.V. Rajagopal of the Ekta Parishad, doing away with the consent clause means the government can just "bulldoze" its way around. "This is a dangerous trend."
He said the amendment providing for compulsory employment to a farm labourer's family doesn't make sense.
"There are so many people eking out a livelihood from a piece of land. So you render thousands of people unemployed and provide jobs to only a few. And what is the level of employment you are guaranteeing," Rajagopal wondered.
"A decent farmer will end up as a security guard in some industry," he said.
He demanded a "radical change" in the bill and said government amendments were cosmetic.
The bill, which was passed in the Lok Sabha on Tuesday, faces a tough test in the Rajya Sabha, where the government is in minority.
Most activists said they hope the upper house manages to stall the bill.
Ramesh Sharma, another land rights activist, told IANS that the central government has put the onus of the social impact assessment on the state governments, which is not right.
He also said that in case of litigation there should be provisions providing legal aid to poor people when they fight cases against the rich industry bodies.
Thousands of activists had gathered in the capital in the last week of February to protest against the new land bill.
The industry has, however, welcomed the bill.
The Confederation of Indian Industry (CII) said: "It is heartening to note that the new amendments take into consideration the interest of all stake holders, especially the land owners."
"Industry welcomes some of the key provisions of the new bill including setting up of State Land Bank Corporations and providing for acquisition up to one km on either side of roads and highways," it said in a statement.
"The amended land bill, if approved in the Rajya Sabha, would be a major boon to the infrastructure goals of the nation. This will accelerate economic growth, create millions of new jobs and improve living standards of every Indian."
Comments
| Quick linksNews
National
International
Regional
Politics
Education & Career
Business
Science & Technology
Health
Views & Analysis
The Funny Side
© 2012 Awaz Multimedia & Publications. All rights reserved.
The release of separatist leader Masrat Alam in Jammu and Kashmir created uproar in both houses of parliament even as Prime Minister Narendra Modi clarified that the central government was not . .... More
Also Read: 'Acquisition of tribal land will lead to spurt in Maoist activities'
While the firm announced the move is because of his age as Facebook requires users to be at least 13- years-old, Pearson believes the social media site has singled him out, NY Daily News reported.. .... More
Also Read: 8th All India Holy Quran competition opens at Jamia Islamiya Akkalkuwa
Assam's man lynched in the most barbaric manner, national media played irresponsibly
Was the victim holy? Was he innocent? We cannot claim anything with certainty. The Indian criminal court is the only right authority to pass a judgment on this in due time. But with whatever hard and ....... More
An Arab, looking rather like the late King Abdullah of Saudi Arabia, is in the driver's seat, keeping a firm grip on four reins strapped not to horses but to four burly, hooded ISIS militants. According to this perception, the ISIS is a Western, Saudi asset. .... More
The National Student's Federation (NSF) organised the formation of a human shield on Friday, the demonstration is an attempt to promote interfaith coexistence and cooperation among different religious and ethnic groups in Pakistan, Dawn reported. .... More
After humiliating the Muslim NGOs and calling all their leaders fool, Zafar Sareshwala is now trying to convince All Indian Muslim Personal Law Board (AIMPLB) President Rabey Hasani Nadwi for a meeting of the senior members of the highest body . .... More
The National Student's Federation (NSF) organised the formation of a human shield on Friday, the demonstration is an attempt to promote interfaith coexistence and cooperation among different religious and ethnic groups in Pakistan, Dawn reported. .... More
Also Read: Holi revellers caught between 'rang barse' and 'run barse'