More on Ummid : International l National Regional l Politics Sports Religion l History l Culture l Education



Not The One You Know



The way people are

actually living in Malegaon surprised the French student

Says, I didn't find any tension between the people in the town

Friday January 23, 2009 07:25:26 PM IST, Aleem Faizee




More About Malegaon

Forgotten Heroes: “I have always wondered how, the Muslims and the Hindus together, had decided to set a Mandir on fire”, said Dr. Iftekhar...Read Full

An Information Outlet: Urdu Library in Malegaon turned 100 this year and the library, which has helped many Ph. Ds in their research work, is all..Read Full

The Power of Reading: One enters the P. B. Kakani Vachnalay and it will be realized immediately that it is not just a library but is “an enlightening nucleus”, guiding generations of Malegaon...Read Full


Galmourous Malegaon

A Real Time Hero: “I was seriously injured in an accident while I went to Dhule once in 1987 on my motor cycle. With my chin dismantled and few...Read Full


attracts Global Media: After making the news in print and electronic media over the years at National level... Read Full




Malegaon, a town in India with more than 70% Muslim population has always been considered as a communally sensitive place. However, there is a place in Malegaon where a Mosque and a Mandir exist side by side with Muslims and Hindus, both living there in peace since last many years. Same is the case with the whole town. Except for the selected few who always try to create trouble, the whole town comprises the peace loving people . Still, the tag of being a communally sensitive place is attributed with the town...Full Story




Communal Harmony Campaign in Malegaon

  • Let’s work to bring a change: “Deadly RDX was invented by Alfred Nobel but we find Peace Prizes being given every year in his name. At one time training camps and hijacking classes were order of the day in United States. However it witnessed...Read Full

  • Confidence overrule the fear: The returned figure of the references resulting after a keyword search about Malegaon at any search engine on the Internet is impressive enough to envy any place. However a glance at the list relating the town with the riots and the bomb blast is so embarrassing that people are becoming shy of associating themselves with...Read Full

  • Malegaon to host Communal Harmony Week:Supported by several organizations and educational institutions of the town, Malegaon Municipal Corporation is organizing a Communal Harmony and National Integration program in terror stricken Malegaon that will commence on Wednesday November 19, 2008. The program that will continue for a whole week will be inaugurated by State Minority Commission Chairman Naseem Siddiquee at 11:00 in the...Read Full

  • Economy will bounce back soon: Even as the world is shaking due to the economic slowdown, back home we are lucky to be among some of the few countries that are saved from a total collapse. But the marginal impact of the global recession on the Indian economy in itself is sufficient to bring the alarm bells ringing. Experts are divided over what actually went wrong that the world is experiencing one of the worst crises....Read Full


Moreon ummid

Inquilab 1857 to Sacchar Report-Nothing has changed for Indian Muslims: Leaving behind the dark memories of the renewed terror and trauma for the Muslims in India... Read Full

‘Advising Restraint, work for the Revival of the Community’: We should advise the Indian Muslims for observing total restraint so that the Anti-Muslim...Read Full

'Give the Indian Muslims ten years of

peace': True, the Government initiatives, schemes and policies take time and if they are related to Muslims...Read Full


Sare Jahan Se Accha

Hindustan Hamara

In 1905 more than 100 years from today, when Iqbal was a lecturer at the Government College, Lahore he was invited by his student Lala Hardayal to preside over a function. Instead of making a speech, Iqbal sang Sare Jahan Se Accha Hindustan Hamara in his style. Iqbal compiled this poem in praise of India and the poem preaches the communal harmony that had unfortunately started ceasing in India by that time. Each and every word in this poem depicts an Indian’s respect and love for the motherland and the values the Indian society inherited for long...Read Full

Sarah, the French student is working

on Communal riots in Malegaon

Sarah Minhia, a French national and student of politics at Institute of Political Studies Lille, France (Institut d’ etudes politiques de Lille, France) had recently visited Malegaon for her research work on the Communal Riots in Malegaon. Malegaon has seen several communal riots in the past. But the October 2001 riot was the worst that the town had seen in its history. The intensity of the October conflict can be gauged from the remarks expressed by few political observers and analysts who after the Gujarat carnage in 2002 had said that whatever had happened in Malegaon in October 2001 was the rehearsal of Gujarat 2002 carnage.


In this exclusive interview, Sarah shared her valuable views about the town with Aleem Faizee for ummid.com readers. While expressing surprise over the total harmony with which the natives of the town are generally living in Malegaon, she suggested various means for further strengthening the communal accord.

The Excerpts:


Communal riots are not rare in India. The 2002 Gujarat riot was virtually genocide. Of late nearby Dhule had also gone through a communal conflict. So why have you chosen Malegaon for your research work?

I first visited India in August 2007 when I came to Pune for my earlier research work on Sociology of India. During my nine months stay in India, I started enjoying the country. At the same time while working on my topic I realized that the focus of my study is concentrating just on Hindus, the majority community in India. I decided to widen my research but I was surprised to know that not much is available on the sociology of other communities and people belonging to other religions. Nevertheless I somehow managed to complete my project but somewhere inside my mind I was feeling uneasiness and wanted to do something more on India. When I consulted my Research Guide Sharmila Reje of Pune University she suggested me to work on the communal riots in Malegaon.


Malegaon, I had never heard of this place before. (Not even after the September 2008 blast in the town when in a surprising breakthrough, Maharashtra Anti Terrorist Squad (ATS) arrested the terrorists associated with Hindu right wing terrorist organization and Malegaon was into the limelight of the national and international media till Mumbai underwent worst kind of terrorist attack in November 2008, she said replying to a pointed question) A hugely Muslim populated town with a series of communal restlessness so near to Pune where I had lived for almost a year was really a surprise for me.


A totally unknown and unfamiliar place for you, how did you plan your research work?

When I began gathering information about Malegaon, to my surprise I found enough contents about the town on Internet. The riots, the bomb blasts and all kinds of bad things about Malegaon, I found most of the things on Internet. Though these contents were related to my project and were helpful it was amazing to find so many bad things associated to a single town with such a sizeable Muslim majority and almost zilch about its virtues. This was enough for me to plan a visit to the town.


The contents on the Internet and widespread speculations in the media about Malegaon must have created a particular perception in your mind about the town. What was your first reaction when you arrived in Malegaon?

Honestly speaking I expected and was prepared for a strange and hostile kind of environment in Malegaon. But believe me I was delighted to see the harmony with which people in general are living in this town. After few minutes ride in and around the town, all my apprehensions were blown into the air.


Yet it is a fact that the town has seen a series of communal conflicts and even today it is regarded as one of the most communally sensitive place in India. You are in the town since last one week and you have spoke to various people from both the communities, what in your view is the root cause of the trouble?

The root cause of the problem in my view is the lack of education. After meeting several people it seems that a kind of political agenda is certainly playing a pivotal role in inciting the trouble between the communities not only in Malegaon but also in other parts of India. It is really strange to see few political parties in this country are solely working on religious based politics. In an attempt to get the political mileage they incite the tension between two communities. Illiterate mob easily becomes prey to their trap. Trouble begins and gives clear advantage to these political parties.


In Malegaon basic structural development is the other area of concern. People it seems have lost the faith in the system. Such environments give way to provocation and small incident under such conditions can at any time be exploited to incite big communal conflict. What surprised me the most is the clear distinction between two parts of the town. While one part of the town where Hindus are residing is having comparatively better civil and other amenities, the other part where more than 75% population of the town comprising of people from the Muslim community are living, does not get the needed care from the administration.


However by maintaining total peace and harmony in the town first after the blast in September 2006 and then again after the recent blast in September 2008, people have demonstrated that violent reactions are the bygone for the town and people here have learnt to live together.


What do you suggest for further strengthening the communal accord in Malegaon?

One thing I have seen in Malegaon is that while there are many NGOs working in the town, like Malegaon they are also divided on communal lines. I have met people working with Muslim NGOs and Hindu NGOs but failed to find anyone who is part of a NGO where Muslims and Hindus are jointly working for a common cause. The town badly needs few NGOs comprising of the people from both the communities. Also, it is needed that instead of limiting their activities to the educated people, the NGOs should also work among the illiterate masses in the town. Moreover the town should have more and more inter-community dialogues and frequent gatherings where people


You have gone through the details of the riots that occurred in Malegaon. The details of the casualties and material losses are in front of you. Despite being in majority, Muslims in Malegaon have suffered heavily in the riots. Amazingly the people who died in police firing are also from the Muslim community. Do you think the police fail in containing the riots? Do you think increasing number of Muslims and people from other religions into the police force is a solution?

While I would not comment on the role of police, I must say that the police force in India is not professional. However increasing the number of people from Muslim community and from other religions is not a solution for better policing. Policeman is a policeman. One should not differentiate them on the basis of his or her religion. What India requires is a professionally trained police force with an open mindset.


Are you planning any more research work in India?

As I told you I am really enjoying your country and I am planning to work on few more projects after completing my research work on Malegaon riots. The immediate topics I am willing to work on are Special Economic Zones (SEZ) and Slums in Mumbai.


Valuable suggestions from Sarah Minhia indeed. Sarah traveled from France to Malegaon specially for her research work on Malegaon Communal riots. Despite her busy schedule she took time off for this interview.


















 Home | Top of the page      


  Your Ad Here


  Comment on this article


E-mail Address:
Write here...

Is India going the way of 1930s Germany?

The recent rounds of violence between religious groups in India do more than reveal the fragility of India's secular state. They highlight the inability of Indian democracy to combat what is essentially a fascist onslaught. At first glance what is happening in India appears to be another - if extreme - case of religious passion gone awry. A train carrying Hindu activists from the disputed religious site of Ayodhya was firebombed by a mob, killing 58 of the activists...Full Story




  Your Ad Here


Ummid.com: Home | Contact Us | Disclaimer | Terms of Use | About Us | Feedback

Ummid Business: Advertise with us | Careers | Link Exchange

Ummid.com is part of Awaz Multimedia & Publications providing World News, News Analysis and Feature Articles on Education, Health. Politics, Technology, Sports, Entertainment, Industry etc. The articles or the views displayed on this website are for public information and in no way describe the editorial views. The users are entitled to use this site subject to the terms and condition mentioned.