Ummid Assistant

Applications open for Manmohan scholarship at Cambridge

IIM-Trichy to offer short courses too at Chennai centre

Welcome Guest! You are here: Home Views & Analysis

With parliament victory, UPA on firmer wicket

Saturday December 08, 2012 07:58:22 PM, Amulya Ganguli, IANS

Related Articles

Government wins FDI battle, says reforms on track

The UPA government Friday dealt a major blow to the opposition in the Rajya Sabha by winning a vote on FDI in retail by 14 votes and declared that there was no stopping  

N.K. Singh chaired FDI panel during NDA: Anand Sharma

With Mayawati's support, UPA eyes SP in Rajya Sabha FDI vote

The consolation which the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) is trying to derive from the fact that the Congress is in a minority in the Lok Sabha on the issue of FDI in the retail sector, although the ruling United Progressive Alliance (UPA) won by 253 votes to 218, is only a solace for the mind with little political consequence. The scope for mental relief has been further diminished by the UPA's victory in the Rajya Sabha.

It isn't only that numbers matter in a democracy but also the winning combination, especially where no single party has an absolute majority. The Congress trumped the BJP on both counts since the latter could not muster enough votes to carry its motion on FDI, and also because the BJP's failure was due to the unwillingness of those, viz., the Samajwadi Party (SP) and the Bahujan Samaj Party (BSP), to stand by it although their opposition to FDI echoed the BJP's position.

Yet the SP and the BSP calculated that staying away from the BJP was politically more profitable than allowing Wal-Mart and other international retail giants to enter the Indian market to the supposed disadvantage of the Indian shopowners. The SP's and the BSP's reasoning was that proximity to the "communal" BJP would alienate their minority vote banks, comprising both Muslims and Christians, whose numbers are estimated to be larger than that of the disaffected shopowners.

Only the Left did not think that its base among the minorities will be affected by its closeness to the BJP. In the case of the communists, it is evident that their ideological antipathy towards FDI in retail, which they see as the front paw of neo-imperialism, is stronger than their desire to hold on to minority support.

In addition, the Left's anti-Congress animus is fuelled not only by politics but also by the belief that the Congress is playing the neo-imperialists' game. The comrades are seemingly not bothered by the fact that by lining up with the BJP, they are bolstering the "communal" elements. For them, the Congress is the bigger enemy, and the enemy of the enemy, the BJP, is, therefore, a friend.

A similar mindset persuaded two other "secular" regional parties, the AIADMK and the Trinamool Congress, to vote against the FDI along with the BJP although they camouflaged their action by saying that the government was anti-poor. While the AIADMK's stance is explained by the fact that the Congress is in alliance with the DMK in Tamil Nadu, where the two Dravida Kazhagams are mortal enemies, the Trinamool Congress has no option but to adopt a stridently pro-poor position to outflank the commissars in West Bengal where it has recently defeated them after a three-decade-long battle.

The perception of the economic reforms being against the poor is a legacy of the 1947-1991 period of a controlled economy when socialistic views prevailed. Among the Congress's supporters, the SP and the BSP are still guided by these beliefs. However, what the voting trends emphasised was the kind of political imperatives which motivated the various parties. Therefore, the point to note is whether the Congress will be able to retain its allies. As of now, the possibility is high - and can become more durable if Narendra Modi's success in Gujarat in the assembly elections strengthens the BJP's communal image.

With the SP and the BSP expected to continue providing outside support, the UPA is now better placed than the BJP-led National Democratic Alliance (NDA). Considering that this is the NDA's second defeat in a parliamentary contest - the first was on the nuclear deal in 2008 - the UPA's position is obviously more secure. What is more, it does not seem to have been affected by the allegations of scams which it has been facing for more than a year.

If the success in 2008 was a watershed in the realm of foreign policy with India abandoning non-alignment and forming closer ties with the US, the latest parliamentary victory is a thumbs-up for reforms and an end of the Congress's earlier socialistic preferences. Even if there are roadblocks ahead because of the BJP's cussedness which may come in the way of the legislation on insurance, pension funds and banking, the earlier dithering by the Congress on reforms, mainly because of resistance from the "socialists" in the party, can be said to have been largely overcome.

While the green signal for FDI in retail should have a positive impact on the investment climate, giving a boost to the economy in the run-up to 2014, another factor which will help the UPA is the new policy of direct cash transfers to the needy. The scene for the Congress is, therefore, brighter than what it was a few months ago.

(Amulya Ganguli is a political analyst. He can be reached at






Home | Top of the Page


Note: By posting your comments here you agree to the terms and conditions of

Comments powered by DISQUS



More Headlines

Unification of India, Pakistan must to solve Kashmir issue: Katju

Karnataka minister sacked, MP suspended for supporting Yeddyurappa

Hamas leader makes historic visit to Gaza

Avoid breast cancer with fruits, vegetables

US, industry giants differ with UN over Internet control

Huge rise in NRK deposits in Kerala banks

India's human rights record comes under attack

World body suspends Indian boxing; government derecognises archery

Traders' body to start nationwide stir

Goa university to track Indian migration patterns

England take decisive lead in Eden Test


Top Stories

Government wins FDI battle, says reforms on track

The UPA government Friday dealt a major blow to the opposition in the Rajya Sabha by winning a vote on FDI in retail by 14 votes and declared that there was no stopping India's reform  

N.K. Singh chaired FDI panel during NDA: Anand Sharma

With Mayawati's support, UPA eyes SP in Rajya Sabha FDI vote


  Most Read

Akbarabadi mosque case: ASI gets more time to conduct survey

The Delhi High Court Friday granted more time to the Archaeological Survey of India (ASI) to file its report on its probe to ascertain if any Mughal-era mosque structure existed near Subhash Park  

World body suspends Indian boxing; government derecognises archery

After the International Olympic Committee (IOC) and the world boxing body AIBA, it was the turn of the sports ministry to get into to the act Friday by de-recognising the Archery Association of India (AAI) and suspending the Indian Boxing Federation (IABF). The government took  


  News Pick

India reaffirms unwavering support to Palestine

India Thursday reaffirmed its unwavering support to the people of Palestine and reiterated its belief that a just, comprehensive and  

Magnitude 7.3 quake jolts Japan, tsunami warning lifted

An earthquake measuring 7.3 on the Richter scale Friday jolted the east coast of Honshu island, leading to a tsunami warning for the coastal areas which was later lifted in Miyagi prefecture, Xinhua reported. The quake  

Drugs, chillums, phones, condoms in a Goa prison!

Drugs, chillums, mobile phones, fancy razors, exotic condoms... No it's not the flea market we are talking about. Welcome to the standard fare in Goa's oldest and most secure - the Aguada Central Jail.  

Karnataka releases Cauvery water to Tamil Nadu

Bowing to the Supreme Court's directive, Karnataka has begun releasing Cauvery river water to Tamil Nadu, thus avoiding contempt of court. Chief Minister Jagadish Shettar thereafter flew to New  

Protests in Karnataka over Cauvery water to Tamil Nadu


Picture of the Day

Tri Service Chiefs paying homage at Amar Jawan Jyoti, India Gate on the occasion of Navy Day in New Delhi on December 04, 2012.


Recommend the story to your friends



RSS  |  Contact us


| Quick links



Subscribe to

Ummid Assistant



Science & Technology



About us




Government Schemes










Contact us


The Funny Side

Education & Career

    Disclaimer | Terms of Use | Advertise with us | Link Exchange is part of the Awaz Multimedia & Publications providing World News, News Analysis and Feature Articles on Education, Health. Politics, Technology, Sports, Entertainment, Industry etc. The articles or the views displayed on this website are for public information and in no way describe the editorial views. The users are entitled to use this site subject to the terms and conditions mentioned.

2012 Awaz Multimedia & Publications. All rights reserved.