Toronto: Transitioning from fossil fuels to electric-powered technology is widely believed to be the best way to lower carbon emissions.
But is that the real solution? Certainly not, especially in India and China, warns a new study.
"Knowing where the electricity comes from to power those 'eco-alternatives' is critical," said researcher Chris Kennedy of the University of Toronto.
"If that electricity comes from burning oil and coal, it might mean that green alternatives aren't that green after all," he added.
Although regions may welcome 'green' technology like electric vehicles, high-speed rail and geothermal heating, they aren't green if the electricity to power them creates even more carbon emissions than their oil-driven counterparts, the researcher said.
Kennedy's study proposes a new decision-making threshold for when to move from fossil fuel technology to electric power.
It says that a region needs to produce its electricity at a rate below the threshold - approximately 600 tonnes of carbon dioxide equivalent per gigawatt hour (GWh).
This means that for every gigawatt hour of electricity generated (the power needed to run about 100 homes for a year), less than 600 tonnes of greenhouse gases (measured as 'CO2 equivalent') can be emitted.
If a region's electricity production exceeds this 600-tonne threshold, such as in countries like India, Australia and China, electrification could actually increase carbon emissions and accelerate climate change, the study warned.
"Countries such as these generate much of their electricity using coal, which produces about 1,000 tonnes of CO2 equivalent per GWh - nearly double the suggested threshold," the researcher said.
Natural gas, on the other hand, produces 600 tonnes, and hydropower and nuclear energy produce nearly zero.
"You could speculate that incorporating electrified technologies such as high speed rail in China may not lower overall emissions. It might even be more carbon friendly to fly," Kennedy said.
The study was published in the journal Nature Climate Change.
Comments
| Quick linksNews
National
International
Regional
Politics
Education & Career
Business
Science & Technology
Health
Views & Analysis
The Funny Side
© 2012 Awaz Multimedia & Publications. All rights reserved.
The BBC aired the documentary on Wednesday night, advancing the date from its scheduled March 8 broadcast. Support for the documentary has built up among people after they saw the documentary.. .... More
Also Read: India examining BBC showing Delhi rape documentary, planning action
In a quick damage control, the Rashtrapati Bhavan Thursday denied reports that President Pranab Mukherjee has refused to visit Israel unless it is accompanied by a visit to Palestine. . .... More
The decision by the BJP-Shiv Sena alliance government to scrap the reservation for Muslims in educational institutions despite the Bombay High Court ruling is politically incorrect and the saffron alliance, known for its anti-Muslim image, by doing .... More
Also Read: Maharashtra scraps reservation for Muslims
An Arab, looking rather like the late King Abdullah of Saudi Arabia, is in the driver's seat, keeping a firm grip on four reins strapped not to horses but to four burly, hooded ISIS militants. According to this perception, the ISIS is a Western, Saudi asset. .... More
Even the reticent and reclusive heir apparent cannot be unaware that a spell far away from the madding crowd will not be long enough for him, or anyone else, to understand why the party is facing an "existential" crisis, to quote one of the 44-year-old prince's. . ... More
A ten-year-old Palestinian boy from Gaza, despite suffering from autism - a disorder of brain development, experience difficulties in social interaction, verbal and nonverbal communication and repetitive behaviors, has memorized the Holy Quran in. .... More
Also Read: Saudi King Salman had memorized entire Quran at the age of 12
The Mumbai Muslim leaders had to face an awkward situation Wednesday when Eknath Khadse, Minister of Awkaf and Minority Development Department in Maharashtra, questioned their silence over the conduct of successive Congress .... More
Also Read: Handle with care: Vajpayee aide to Fadnavis on Ismail Yusuf College