Washington: It would be unfair to portray India's banning of a BBC documentary on the gang rape of an Indian woman as a signal of a more authoritarian government, according to a leading US expert.
"Some portray the government's move as an attempt to stifle free speech on an issue that could harm India's image," said Rick Rossow, Wadhwani Chair in US-India Policy Studies Centre for Strategic and International Studies.
This "in a way, is an attempt to turn this issue into a question over whether India's 'strongman leader' Narendra Modi is exhibiting an authoritarian streak many believe he harbours," he said commenting on the ban on the documentary "India's Daughter".
"While there are questions over whether the BBC followed India's procedures, the debate in India is certainly focused on whether the documentary should be blocked due to its content," Rossow said.
"But at the same time, it is unfair to use an overly broad brush and paint this as an issue which Prime Minister Modi is personally trying to avoid," he said.
"Prime Minister Modi has actually been a fairly strong proponent of women's rights, using far less paternalistic language than his predecessors," Rossow said, pointing to his various speeches.
"It is not the first time we have seen free speech attacked in India," he said.
"This BBC dispute, though, should not be taken as indicative of a personal inclination by Prime Minister Modi to ignore the issue of the mistreatment of females."
"Less than a year into his tenure, he has become an unexpected champion of women's rights," Rossow said.
Several US newspapers, including the Washington Post, carried an AP story headlined, "A murderer and rapist's views reflect those of many in India".
The condemned rapist killer Mukesh Singh's reported views that "the woman he and others brutally gang-raped on a New Delhi bus was responsible for what had happened to her", it said "were shocking in their callousness and lack of remorse".
"But the underlying view has wide acceptance in India," it said, suggesting "blaming women for rape is what hundreds of millions of men here are taught to believe".
"But how different were the convicted rapist's words from comments that Manohar Lal Khattar, the top elected official of Haryana state, made last year?" it asked.
The influential New York Times too focused on the rapist's comment "that the young woman invited the rape because she was out too late at night and that she would have lived if she had submitted to the assault".
The comments, released as part of a publicity campaign for the film "were met with outrage in India, in part over why the filmmaker, Leslee Udwin, had been permitted to interview the defendant in jail", it said.
The Los Angeles Times noted that the ban on film about 2012 Delhi gang rape had stirred a debate in India.
(Arun Kumar can be contacted at arun.kumar@ians.in)
Comments
| Quick linksNews
National
International
Regional
Politics
Education & Career
Business
Science & Technology
Health
Views & Analysis
The Funny Side
© 2012 Awaz Multimedia & Publications. All rights reserved.
Amid uproar in parliament over a documentary which featured one of the December 16 gang rape convicts, the home ministry on Wednesday went into damage control mode, saying orders were obtained from court to restrain the broadcast of the .... More
Also Read: December 16 rapist like a robot: BBC Documentary maker
Peoples Conference activists argue that the former separatist leader who joined the electoral fray and won state assembly elections from north Kashmir Handwara constituency last year deserved a better deal so that he could convince his voters that joining mainstream politics would usher in better days . .... More
Government is threatening our livelihood by mixing this trade with religion, meat sellers say
While most of the association members working for the beef traders are still in shock two days after the Maharashtra Animal Preservation (Amendment) Act (MAPA) 1995 is signed .... More
Also Read: Maharashtra becomes 9th state to ban calf slaughter
An Arab, looking rather like the late King Abdullah of Saudi Arabia, is in the driver's seat, keeping a firm grip on four reins strapped not to horses but to four burly, hooded ISIS militants. According to this perception, the ISIS is a Western, Saudi asset. .... More
Even the reticent and reclusive heir apparent cannot be unaware that a spell far away from the madding crowd will not be long enough for him, or anyone else, to understand why the party is facing an "existential" crisis, to quote one of the 44-year-old prince's. . ... More
A ten-year-old Palestinian boy from Gaza, despite suffering from autism - a disorder of brain development, experience difficulties in social interaction, verbal and nonverbal communication and repetitive behaviors, has memorized the Holy Quran in. .... More
Also Read: Saudi King Salman had memorized entire Quran at the age of 12
The Mumbai Muslim leaders had to face an awkward situation Wednesday when Eknath Khadse, Minister of Awkaf and Minority Development Department in Maharashtra, questioned their silence over the conduct of successive Congress .... More
Also Read: Handle with care: Vajpayee aide to Fadnavis on Ismail Yusuf College