Ummid Assistant

Applications open for Manmohan scholarship at Cambridge

IIM-Trichy to offer short courses too at Chennai centre

Welcome Guest! You are here: Home Education & Career

Unfair to withhold student's degree for dues: Consumer court rules

Wednesday December 12, 2012 12:53:57 PM, Rahul Chhabra, IANS

New Delhi: It is unfair for a university or college to withhold a student's degree to recover dues, the apex consumer court has ruled and said it would be preferable for the institution to move a civil court to get its money back.

"Such kind of practice is not fair," the National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission said in a recent ruling in connection with a case involving Sushith, a student pursuing an MD degree in biochemistry, the Manipal University and the Kasturba Medical College in Karnataka.

The court directed the university and the college to pay Rs.10,000 as compensation to Sushith, 32, before Feb 6, 2013.

The commission's Presiding Member V.B. Gupta also questioned why the college and the university did not move a civil court to recover the alleged dues of Rs.9.3 lakh from Sushith, a resident of Mangalore, whose degree was withheld.

The case reached the national commission after the university and the college appealed against an order of the Karnataka State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission, Bangalore, favouring Sushith.

Sushith's degree was withheld for allegedly breaching an agreement with the university and the college that required him to serve there for five years after completing the course -- failing which he was supposed to repay the entire tuition fee whose burden was borne by them.

The national commission said: "Even if it is held for a while that...the student is liable to refund the tuition fee, the remedy is still open to the university and college to recover the same by approaching an appropriate civil court."

"When such an equally efficacious remedy is readily available to them, they cannot illegally retain the said degree certificate," Gupta said in the order, a copy of which is with IANS.

Sushith said in his complaint that he took admission to post-graduate degree course in MD in biochemistry for academic year 2005-06 and passed the course in 2008.

The college was required to issue him a degree certificate confirmed by the Manipal Academy of Higher Education. But despite repeated requests, it refused to issue the certificate and withheld it, he said.

The college dean and the university registrar said Sushith's original degree certificate was retained as a lien as he owed Rs.9.3 lakh as tuition fee and stipend, which they paid during his course.

They said that they could not be forced to provide the certificate for which they had not received any consideration.

The university and the college claimed that Sushith executed an agreement with them May 23, 2005, along with two sureties but he failed to abide by the conditions incorporated in it and remained away from duty after the course.

He was supposed to start serving in the college from Dec 1, 2008, but allegedly stopped reporting to office from Dec 9, 2008, they said.

The apex consumer commission dismissed their plea and said: "Petitioners have placed on record copy of 'service agreement' dated May 23, 2005, executed between the parties. This agreement does not contain any condition or clause by virtue of which the university/college is entitled to retain the degree/certificate of Sushith as a lien till he performs the terms of the agreement."

Endorsing the findings of the Dakshina Kannada District Consumer Disputes Redressal Forum, Mangalore, and the state commission, Gupta said: "The district forum has properly considered both oral and documentary evidence and rightly come to the conclusion. Retaining of the degree certificate is otherwise compelling the complainant to serve under them. Such kind of practice is not fair."

"The appellant (university and college) have failed to show before this commission that the impugned order under appeal is erroneous, unjust and improper and that it suffers from legal infirmity, is unsustainable in the law and there is error apparent on the face of record requiring our interference. Appeal appears to be devoid of merit," said Gupta.

(Rahul Chhabra can be contacted at




Home | Top of the Page


Note: By posting your comments here you agree to the terms and conditions of

Comments powered by DISQUS



More Headlines

This man strives to keep Islamic art calligraphy alive

Sitar legend Ravi Shankar is dead

North Korea launches long-range rocket: Report

24 foreign TV channels can't telecast in India for lack of permission

Salman Khurshid to visit Myanmar in first bilateral trip

Aligarh forum urges Abbas to invite Hamas for Unity Govt.

British woman gives birth in helicopter

71,397 vacancies in paramilitary forces

Tension in Andhra town after violence during procession

White Britons now a minority in London

UAE kicks off halal standardization worldwide


Top Stories

Modi vs Congress as Gujarat polls begin Thursday

Gujarat's two-phase polling begins Thursday in what is widely seen as a battle between a sanguine Chief Minister Narendra Modi and the Congress, the outcome sure to cast  

Modi says Congress has 'anti-Gujarat mindset'

Gujarat's 'development' touches select few: PM

Modi doesn't listen to ordinary Gujarati: Rahul


  Most Read

Congress does balancing act over job quota bill

Finding itself in a "complex" situation, the Congress is doing a fine balancing act in trying to resolve the Rajya Sabha deadlock over the bill on reservations for the Scheduled Castes and the Scheduled  

Left Front, Trinamool members fight in Bengal assembly, three hurt

The West Bengal assembly Tuesday witnessed unruly scenes as the Left Front and the ruling Trinamool Congress members indulged in fist fighting, resulting in three legislators being injured and hospitalised and three others suspended. The fracas broke out when the Left Front   


  News Pick

UAE kicks off halal standardization worldwide

The Emirates Authority for Standardization and Metrology (Esma) kicked off work on unifying standards for halal foods and cosmetics 

I can look back at life with satisfaction, surprise: Dilip Kumar

On his 90th birthday Tuesday, thespian Dilip Kumar, who has regaled scores of fans over decades, recalls his  

Birthday wishes galore for Dilip Kumar

Akhilesh launches girl education aid scheme, BJP upset

Distributing the cheques to beneficiaries from Moradabad division at the Mohammad Ali Jauhar University campus, Akhilesh Yadav pointed out that the scheme was the brainchild of Urban Development Minister  

Preparations on in Mumbai for 5th AMP annual Career Festival

The two-day annual Career Festival, which will be held on December 15 and 16 at Saboo Siddik Engineering College ground, is supported by MLA and Chairman of Maulana Azad Minorities Financial 


Picture of the Day

Tri Service Chiefs paying homage at Amar Jawan Jyoti, India Gate on the occasion of Navy Day in New Delhi on December 04, 2012.


Recommend the story to your friends



RSS  |  Contact us


| Quick links



Subscribe to

Ummid Assistant



Science & Technology



About us




Government Schemes










Contact us


The Funny Side

Education & Career

    Disclaimer | Terms of Use | Advertise with us | Link Exchange is part of the Awaz Multimedia & Publications providing World News, News Analysis and Feature Articles on Education, Health. Politics, Technology, Sports, Entertainment, Industry etc. The articles or the views displayed on this website are for public information and in no way describe the editorial views. The users are entitled to use this site subject to the terms and conditions mentioned.

2012 Awaz Multimedia & Publications. All rights reserved.