Ummid Assistant

Taj Group to train underprivileged rural youth in Maharashtra

Robotics competition for Andhra school students

Welcome Guest! You are here: Home Views & Analysis

Axing ministers: Sonia's 'inner voice' again ?

Saturday May 11, 2013 06:08:13 PM, IANS

Related Article

Unceremonious Exit

Pawan Kumar Bansal, Aswani Kumar sacked

Within hours of Congress chief Sonia Gandhi meeting Prime Minister Manmohan Singh Friday evening, the UPA government asked two tainted cabinet members 

Pawan Kumar Bansal asked to quit as Railway Minister

Ministers who resigned on corruption charges in UPA II

In a display of assertive leadership, Sonia Gandhi seems to have played a major role in the sacking of the two Union ministers, Ashwini Kumar and Pawan Bansal, whose names had come under a cloud.

The fact that the dismissals took place within hours of her "unscheduled" meeting with Manmohan Singh is not without significance. Aware that any further dithering might irreparably damage the Congress's and the government's image, the Sonia Gandhi saw to it that it was hers, and the party's, views which would ultimately prevail.

In the process, the prime minister's reputation has taken a hit, for it was suspected that he was reluctant to remove the two ministers, and especially Ashwini Kumar, since the latter's sacking would have exposed the prime minister himself to the direct line of fire in the coal mine allocation scandal.

Since the dismissal of the railway minister would have automatically led to the demand for the axing of the law minister as well - as it indeed happened - Manmohan Singh was evidently unwilling to take even the first step. The delay, however, via self-serving explanations, by spokespersons about how everyone was innocent under the law unless proven guilty, and that investigations were on, was proving fatally damaging to the party's credibility.

What was more, it was taking the sheen of the Congress's victory in Karnataka. Arguably, if the Karnataka result had not come out at this particular time, the government might have continued to maintain that there was no need to pre-empt the findings of the probes against Bansal and his relatives, and the Supreme Court's final judgment on Ashwini Kumar, by dismissing them. The willingness to let things drift could be seen in the abrupt decision to adjourn the Lok Sabha sine die to stifle the opposition's demand for the ministerial resignations.

However, what the government appears to have overlooked is the politically damaging consequences of public opinion, moulded to a considerable extent by an overactive media, which suspected a cover-up. This was truer of the law minister since he was seen to have been overzealous in changing the "heart" of the Central Bureau of Investigation's (CBI) report on the coal scam.

Since the prime minister's name has come up in this connection, the surmise was that the law minister tampered with the portions unfavourable to his boss. The presence of bureaucrats from the Prime Minister's Office (PMO) by Ashwini Kumar's side - while he was supposedly correcting grammatical errors in the CBI report to the Supreme Court - deepened the suspicion. For the first time, therefore, since Manmohan Singh became the "accidental" prime minister, his Teflon image no longer seemed adequate.

From the vantage point of being outside the hothouse atmosphere of the government, Sonia Gandhi had evidently sensed that any further dragging of the foot on the two ministers was politically untenable. If the Karnataka verdict brought forward the day of their sacking, the approach of the anniversary of the United Progressive Alliance's (UPA) ninth year in office also made it imperative that Ashwini Kumar and Bansal would be shown the door. The celebratory mood, already not all that upbeat because of a faltering economy, would have been further dampened by their presence in their official capacities.

This is the third time that Sonia Gandhi has been seen in a proactive mood. The first occasion was when she engineered the ouster of the then party chief, Sitaram Kesri, because of the belief that he was leading the Congress downhill. The second was when her "inner voice" told her that becoming prime minister herself in 2004, as the party wanted, would give an unnecessary handle to a demoralized Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) to dramatize the "foreign national" issue and claw its way backs into public reckoning. Hence, her selection of Manmohan Singh.

Her latest act is the third time that she has taken a decisive step on what can be deemed an "official" matter. However, the initiative is in line with the satisfaction she expressed when Ashok Chavan and Shashi Tharoor resigned from their ministerial positions a few years ago. (Tharoor has since been rehabilitated.) She said at the time that while the BJP talked, the Congress acted.

This time, too, she could not but have noted how the electorate punished the BJP in Karnataka. It is also not impossible that she recalled how the Congress itself lost its massive majority in the Lok Sabha in 1989 because of the Bofors howitzer scandal.

She realized, therefore, that the party's prospects would be dim if it approached the forthcoming state assembly elections in Madhya Pradesh, Chhattisgarh, Rajasthan and Delhi, and the general election thereafter, with a tainted image. As for the Karnataka outcome, it is obvious that the Congress did not win so much - after all, its voting percentages remained virtually static - as that the BJP lost with a steep 13 per cent drop in its vote share.

If the ministerial dismissals mark the beginning of an effort to cleanse the Augean stables of sleaze, it will be an eagerly awaited initiative by the people of India.

(Amulya Ganguli is a political analyst. He can be reached at






Home | Top of the Page


Note: By posting your comments here you agree to the terms and conditions of

Comments powered by DISQUS


More Headlines

Fuel hike makes petrol cheaper than diesel in Goa

Pakistanis brave terror threat, turn up to vote

Muslims must stop playing loathsome politics with Vande Mataram

Voting begins in Pakistan

SC dismisses Sanjay Dutt's plea for review of conviction

Law Minister Ashwani Kumar too shown door: Report

JNU, DU English departments among world's top 100

Blast in Maharashtra bus, 15 injured

Pawan Kumar Bansal asked to quit as Railway Minister

Diesel price to go up by 90 paise per litre

A woman as Delhi Police commissioner?


Top Stories

Unceremonious Exit

Pawan Kumar Bansal, Aswani Kumar sacked

Within hours of Congress chief Sonia Gandhi meeting Prime Minister Manmohan Singh Friday evening, the UPA government asked two tainted cabinet members 

Pawan Kumar Bansal asked to quit as Railway Minister

Ministers who resigned on corruption charges in UPA II


  Most Read

Race for Chief Minister

Congress names Siddaramaiah Karnataka CM

"The party high command has named Siddaramiah as chief minister of Karnataka," Defence Minister A.K. Antony, who heads  

How Siddaramaiah pipped Kharge to Karnataka CM post

More Congress leaders jump into Karnataka CM race

Pakistan Elections

Violence, abduction and a fall: turbulent run-up to Pakistan polls

Pakistan was on the edge Friday, a day before it goes to the polls to decide the fate of 23,000 candidates who stayed on despite a volatile run-up that saw at least 100 people being killed in a series of terror attacks and former prime minister Yousuf Raza  


  News Pick

A miracle! Dhaka woman survives 16 days under rubble

A woman was Friday found alive, trapped in the rubble of the collapsed eight-storey building on the outskirts of this Bangladesh capital, 16 days after the disaster that has claimed  

Jamia Millia prepares 'brains' to help India understand neighbours

Jamia Millia Islamia, one of the country's oldest universities, has embarked upon a series of country-specific programmes to prepare a cadre of experts to fulfil the research needs of the government and think tanks, something  

Role Models

The Maulanas who are imparting competitive ability in Muslim youth

On the other end of the spectrum of the Indian society are the images of successful bright Indian youth who compete fiercely for top professional  

Stephen Hawking joins academic boycott of Israel

The wheelchair-bound Hawking, who has won international recognition for his work on black holes, had been due to speak at a prestigious conference in June organised by Israeli President  


Picture of the Day

Parvez Naikwadi (left) and Shakeel Ansari met Maharashtra Chief Minister Prithviraj Chavan on Moday. The two are among the 30 Muslims who have  cleared the 2012 UPSC Mains Exams. Also seen in the picture is Minister of Minority Development Department Arif Naseem Khan.


Recommend the story to your friends



RSS  |  Contact us


| Quick links



Subscribe to

Ummid Assistant



Science & Technology



About us




Government Schemes










Contact us


The Funny Side

Education & Career Disclaimer | Terms of Use | Advertise with us | Link Exchange is part of the Awaz Multimedia & Publications providing World News, News Analysis and Feature Articles on Education, Health. Politics, Technology, Sports, Entertainment, Industry etc. The articles or the views displayed on this website are for public information and in no way describe the editorial views. The users are entitled to use this site subject to the terms and conditions mentioned.

2012 Awaz Multimedia & Publications. All rights reserved.